Pie

“Four and Twenty is the best pie I’ve had in my life, so if you’re willing to double your budget I’d recommend that.”

“Easily Petee's and its not even close.”

“Omg it’s life changing !! I bring one of their pies anytime I’m invited to someone’s home for dinner & they’re always a hit !!!”

“Manhattan: favorite pie was Rubirosa and favorite slice was mama’s too (for Sicilian) or stretch (sell slices until 4 or 5pm I forget)”

“They have a bk location? Definitely one of the best pies in the city.”

“and agree the pie was insane”

“CMV: Lucky Charlie has got the best pie in the city.”

“The fries at Lord’s are absolutely insane, and the steak & pies phenomenal.”

“BL: favorite pie was Chrissy’s and favorite slice was Best Pizza”

“Third. Steve’s and nothing comes close. It’s out there but he regularly delivers to Citarella so you can try getting a pie there.”

“The pie from Kora on the other hand was phenomenal and the craft so elevated, and they don’t sell out.”

“Not NYC but Razza is my favorite pie in the area”

“I'd do whatever pie the Dutch has going on for dessert. Their pies are fantastic.”

“Metro Diner has amazing pies and is fun people watching. Great spot for a super casual date night!”

“Seemed like the coolest pies tho”

“if you can eat the whole pie then lindustrie ~ and yes, they are excellent”

“The pies were fab, true NY style and a pan pie that had great crunch (I usually prefer very thin crust so for me to opt in for the pan pie from here means a lot).”

“Luigi's is nearly as good or just as good depending on your preference and slightly cheaper without the wait.”

“You went to milk bar without getting the pie? You’re fuckin up.”

“Agreed this was great and quite affordable for a whole pie”

“I can confirm patsy is essy to crush a pie by yourself- its very thin and delicious.”

“Excellent pies also”

“Great pies too... everything there is good”

“Her cakes get all the attention but she has wonderful pies”

“I pick up stuff from myers of keswick, you cant eat in but everything they do is excellent. Whole butcher counter with all the back bacon and sausages, pies, pasties, and scotch eggs!”

“Miss Mamie’s Spoonbread has food and a few amazing pies on W 110th”

“Fried chicken, pies, biscuits, all great.”

“When the pie comes right out of oven and the dough is on point no better”

“Their signature pie (peaches, apples, and blueberries) is really good!”