8.3/10
AI-generated summary
All of it is good, but people push the hardest, especially the salty chocolate one. The is the other regular pick. A whole runs about $45, which people call steep. Some prefer Four and Twenty Blackbirds and say Petee's fruit pies lean cornstarchy.
“Petee's Pie has to be hands down the best Apple Pie. I went during the pandemic almost every weekend to get one whole pie for comfort and devour this bad boy. I loved it and still do. It's flakey, buttery and the apple is just perfectly crunchy/soft combining it all together.”
H3
“Thanksgiving Pies from Librae, Petee's Pie, Four and Twenty Blackbirds”
H2
“Petee's pies has the best pies. I did a pretty extensive taste-test for my wedding and they were the winner.”
H2
“apple pie from petee’s pie!”
H2
“I’d go to the nearest Petee’s pie afterwards. It might not have a sit down ambiance but the pie is top notch.”
H2
“Petee’s pies are around $45 normally which is already steep for a pie, but probably worth it.”
H2
“I love taking people to Petee's, LES location. Takeaway pie slices and homemade ice cream, and if you ask they're cool about bringing a bottle of bubbles (or whatever) and posting up on their table with slices and bubbles.”
H2
“Petee's sour cherry pie is great!”
H2
“Petee's Pies for -- the pies (I like the cherry crumb and the various chess pies)”
H2
“Thanksgiving Pies from Librae, Petee's Pie, Four and Twenty Blackbirds”
H2
“Petees beats four & twenty, imho. Their fruit pies are fantastic but their chess pies are INSANE.”
H2
“Got their chocolate cream literally this afternoon. Can confirm”
H2