“Steve’s is hands-down the worst key lime pie I’ve had. It’s extremely sugary. The filling skimps on the lime and is mostly filler and condensed milk.”
H3
7.4/10
AI-generated summary
They only make , and most people say it's worth the trip to Red Hook. Get a slice or the Swingle, which is on a stick dipped in chocolate. The trek out there is the main gripe. A few people find it too sweet and light on real lime flavor, but the common view is tart, creamy and made with actual key limes.
“Steve’s is hands-down the worst key lime pie I’ve had. It’s extremely sugary. The filling skimps on the lime and is mostly filler and condensed milk.”
H3
“Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in Red Hook is pretty great. They only make Key Lime pies though.”
H2
“then get key lime Steve's.”
H2
“Steve's, yes - Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is the way. 💯”
H2
“If you don't mind a schlep- Steve's Key Lime Pie in Red Hook.”
H2
“Steve’s Key Lime Pie.”
H2
“Steves definitely but Red Hook is tough to get to.”
H2
“Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in Red Hook”
H2
“Steve’s authentic key lime pie. I love key lime pie”
H2
“Steve’s Key Lime Pie.”
H2
“Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie”
H2
“Steve’s in Red Hook is VERY good.”
H2