“My opinion is that Chrissy’s is good but has a couple fatal flaws. It’s very expensive. They only serve pies. And it’s a rich tasting pie. The flavors and crust are great.”
H3
5.9/10
AI-generated summary
Whole pies only, no slices, and a runs around $35. The crust is thin, crisp and sauce forward, and fans put it among the best in the city. Expect a line and expect them to run out of dough. Plenty of people think it's overrated once you add up the price and the wait.
“My opinion is that Chrissy’s is good but has a couple fatal flaws. It’s very expensive. They only serve pies. And it’s a rich tasting pie. The flavors and crust are great.”
H3
“She loves it”
H3
“This was my first time and I thought this was great! No flop, crust was thin/crispy but firm. Not too cheesy which I don’t mind. 4/5”
H2
“Worth the hype!”
H2
“NY-style pizza (L’Industrie, Cello’s, Chrissy’s)”
H2
“That being said, pizza was fine and 35 dollars for a single pie.”
H2
“My absolute favorite is the tomato pie at Chrissy’s — it’s a must do.”
H2
“Recently been going to Chrissy’s, expensive but very good”
H2
“Better than Chrissy’s, cheaper than Chrissy’s, nicer than Chrissy’s, quicker than Chrissy’s.”
H2
“Had both a couple weeks back. Been meaning to go since I live nearby-ish. Was underwhelmed with both tbh. Both solid, but I think I’m finding I don’t prefer the heavier/crispier cook that so many of the new wave places favor.”
H2
“I actually thought Chrissy's was fantastic. They were also super nice and gave us a free pie after they accidentally messed up our order, so maybe that skews my perspective :)”
H2
“Pizza was fantastic. I thought it was just as good as when he was making it in the old SB space in 2023 but my girlfriend thought it was better then.”
H2