“worth the hype, sorry. The cereal milk soft serve is truly great, buttery, salty, sweet and creamy. With the cereal topping for more texture it becomes even better.”
H3
4.2/10
AI-generated summary
This one splits people hard. The common complaint is that everything is cloyingly sweet and tastes mass produced since the expansion. Fans still swear by the , the , and the . Skip the packaged stuff in grocery stores, people say it's much worse than the shop.
“worth the hype, sorry. The cereal milk soft serve is truly great, buttery, salty, sweet and creamy. With the cereal topping for more texture it becomes even better.”
H3
“most of the things they make are really mediocre now.”
H3
“Milk Bar's Birthday Cake is probably perfect. It is high sugar and butter, over the top in all the right ways.”
H3
“The Milk bar legitimately sucks ass. The cereal milk ice cream taste weird and does not taste like cereal milk to me. The former "crack pie" (they renamed it to something else) was basically a sugar pie lol. The cookies are meh”
H3
“Milk bar was good in its original form, but then they expanded and became sort of a factory premade and shipped to their many, many stores thing. It’s now very mediocre.”
H3
“Great actual deep cocoa flavor with some tang in a nice moist cake. Then, the cheesecake and frosting. It was a bit hard to know what was frosting and what was cheesecake when it was all together, but I didn't care. Super thick, rich, creamy, great cream cheese flavor. I quite enjoyed it.”
H3
“the Milk Bar Birthday Cake is the ultimate funfetti cake with artificial vanilla extract that screams childhood and it’s one of my favorite cakes of all time.”
H3
“It tastes just like lemon meringue, is very creamy, and isn't as overly sweet as most of their stuff.”
H3
“Milk Bar has been terrible for years. I keep ordering, including a big birthday cake for my daughter, in hopes of it just being a bad day, but nope. It's terrible. Very, very sweet and it all tastes very over-processed.”
H3
“Great actual deep cocoa flavor with some tang in a nice moist cake. Then, the cheesecake and frosting. It was a bit hard to know what was frosting and what was cheesecake when it was all together, but I didn't care. Super thick, rich, creamy, great cream cheese flavor. I quite enjoyed it.”
H3
“1/5 sorry these were not good, overly sweet, tasted very processed”
H2
“Milk bar is way too sweet”
H2