Miss American PieCLOSED

7.3/10

AI-generated summary

The was apple, peach and blueberry together, and people called it the best they'd had. Regulars said the plain crowd pleasers like and were the real strength. The Park Slope shop closed, though people said they would still make pies to order.

What Reddit says15

View all

in:Your best meals of 2024?42 pts
“Miss American Pie - signature blueberry-peach-apple pie”
in:Let’s talk about peach pie13 pts
“Their signature pie (peaches, apples, and blueberries) is really good!”
in:Let’s talk about peach pie5 pts
“I would check in with Miss American Pie, see if they can make you one.”
in:Best places for pie?3 pts
replying to u/pumper911: Miss American Pie
“Their signature pie (peaches, apples, and blueberries) is really good!”
in:What’s the best apple pie that could be delivered to Prospect Heights? 3 pts
“They had to close their shop on 5th but for my money they had the absolute best "classic" crowd pleaser pies in the borough- apple, peach, etc.”
in:What are your favorite pumpkin flavored desserts in the city?2 pts
“Pumpkin Pie at Miss American Pie”
in:Best places for pie?2 pts
“MISS AMERICAN PIE W FRESH WHIPPED CREAM”
in:BEST apple pie? 2 pts
“It's actually apple with peaches and blueberries and it's insanely good.”
in:Best “sweet treats?”1 pts
replying to u/smc218: Miss American Pie in Park Slope!
“Miss american pie is a amazing, the apple etc one is a huge hit for us”
in:BEST apple pie? 1 pts
replying to u/machiz7888: Miss American Pie. It used to be in park slope but now they seem to be doing popups. It's actually apple with peaches and blueberries and it's insanely good. I get a little tired of typical apple pie like three quarters the way through a slice. But with theirs every bite is just a little different. It's perfect.
“They pulled up this year with that apple, peach, blueberry thing and it was probably the best pie I’ve ever had.”

See all 15 mentions