Bagel

“I usually do an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, onion, tomato & s&p, but I wanted to compare apples to apples with what I ordered at Liberty bagel. Brooklyn Bagel wins hands down.”

“Now go to a hand rolled, boiled bagel shop in the morning (just check out any best bagels list to find one close to where you'll be. Off the top of my head, liberty in midtown is good), and get an everything bagel NOT toasted with a schmear (a little bit of cream cheese) and prepare to have your life changed.”

“The everything bagel was delicious and the scallion cream cheese with lox were incredible together. I think this is maybe the best cream cheese I've ever had.”

“For me the best bagel of 2024 was Pop Up Bagels Everything Bagel.”

“It is currently my favorite plain, onion, and everything bagel in NYC”

“We loved it. The everything bagel was so flavoursome and the texture was perfect. Plus the fillings tasted so fresh. Nothing to be improved on in my opinion!”

“$3.65 for the ultimate everything bagel.”

“Kossar’s was a really delicious bagel, very well seasoned and chewy but not hard to bite into. I’d go back to Kossar’s in a heartbeat, but Zabar’s I’m not sure if was worth it for the price and the walk.”

“yes their everything bagels are amazing!”

“Breakfast #2: **Bagel Shop** (UES) - everything bagel w/ scallion”

“Tal is so stupidly overpriced. I do like the unique quality of their bagel but i was shocked at how much an everything with cream cheese was at the uws location.”

“I got the lox and the everything bagel is heavily seasoned (the way I like it) and sooo crispy. I was in shock when I first tried it.”

“4. Everything bagel not toasted with scallion cc at Pick A Bagel”

“I love how they use carroway seed on their everything bagels”

“Get it on an everything bagel—no need for salt, pepper, ketchup.”

“I think for me, it’s a Barney Greengrass. Latkes, fresh squeezed OJ, a coffee and salty lox and onion scramble with an everything bagel and plain cream cheese.”

“Everything toasted dark with scallion cream cheese. She’s a classic for a reason.”

“7. Toasted everything bagel with Normandy butter at Leo”

“-everything with plain from Murray’s”

“Baz Bagel in Little Italy - everything bagel toasted with nova & chive cream cheese”

“Posting to recommend that you ask for everything, garlic and/or onion bagels to be packaged separately in paper with a plastic bag to tie up.”

“Bergen Bagels are mediocre, their Everything bagel never has enough seasoning and texture is \*fine,\* don't know why it made the cut”

“I’m an everything bagel guy 90% of the time (but do deviate sometimes).”

“It's the best bagel on the planet, particularly the everything.”

“Went to H&H twice, everything bagels were tasteless. I was very disappointed.”

“Zabar’s everything bagel has been my least favorite so far. It’s got oats on it and kind of an odd too sweet flavor profile that doesn’t hit what I’m looking for.”

“I used to go to bagel works but honestly the bagels are small and not that tasty, the everything (works) bagel doesn’t even have everything on it!”

“Gerties is fine for bagels, but their everything bagel is over-everythinged and some of their sandwich and spread options are incredibly overly salty.”

“Everything Bagel with shmear at Essa Bagels. It's no H&H but damn these are good when they are fresh.”