“the egg sandwich was tepid and chewy, the hash made my girl sick. Never again with Gerties, we use it as a joke suggestion when no one can pick a breakfast spot lmao”
H3
5.6/10American
AI-generated summary
Get the . It's small, chewy and dense in the classic New York style, and it's the thing people agree on. The and the pastries get good marks too. The hot breakfast is where the complaints land, and a few people say the spreads and the are too salty.
“the egg sandwich was tepid and chewy, the hash made my girl sick. Never again with Gerties, we use it as a joke suggestion when no one can pick a breakfast spot lmao”
H3
“Gerties is fine for bagels, but their everything bagel is over-everythinged and some of their sandwich and spread options are incredibly overly salty.”
H3
“everything I’ve gotten there has been mid to inedible, but their matzo ball soup is almost always excellent. The pastries are usually good too.”
H2
“Nah, I love Gertie. Their veggie chopped cheese is lowkey fire and their german potato salad fries are crazy”
H2
“GERTIE is a Jewish brunch spot with a colorful & comfortable atmosphere and delicious bagel sandwiches.”
H2
“The Gertie bagel is smaller, chewy and dense, which is more of a classic NY bagel.”
H2
“Gertie's bagel was absolutely amazing as it normally is”
H2
“Agree (grew up in park slope, now live in prospect heights). But it's still in the same style of bagel as bagel hole, which is inherently better than the fat doughy bagel pub transplant bagel”
H2