“Liberty is really good and fast. Their bagels are also very gluten-y and chewy. Their spreads and toppings are fantastic as well.”
5.7/10
AI-generated summary
Get an with one of the many cream cheese flavors, that is what regulars point to. The is surprisingly good too. Skip the , people call it an Instagram trap. The line and the ordering system are chaotic, and plenty of people say it is a solid that is not worth the hype.
“Liberty is really good and fast. Their bagels are also very gluten-y and chewy. Their spreads and toppings are fantastic as well.”
“unfortunately I just don't like this place. The jalapeno everything bagel was just okay, and there was just too much cream cheese (and I love cream cheese!).”
“really good lox and bagel”
“1st one need more cream cheese but it’s good. 2nd one. Perfect. 10/10. 3rd one somehow feels like it’s undercook like ‘I want a lawyer’ bad.”
“Better than Essa, Zucker’s, Tal, not as good as Zabar’s.”
“better bagel - delicious”
“This was a perfectly good bagel, but the system to get it is broken. Not worth the line/ hectic environment IMO.”
“Solid bagel, enjoyed my partners' brisket/egg better than the lox”
“FiDi now officially bagel heaven.”
“bagels (Liberty, Ess-a-bagel, Utopia)”
“Best bagel Liberty bagel”
“Just be forewarned, it’s a very standard bagel. Definitely a little above average, but absolutely not worth the hype or the lines.”