Cookie

“Black and white cookie is my favorite but also sugar overload”

“Omg if you go, get the black and white cookies as well. They are incredible”

“The OG Magnolia bakery is on Bleecker and the best b/w cookies are at orwashers, Russ & daughters and William Greenberg.”

“The OG Magnolia bakery is on Bleecker and the best b/w cookies are at orwashers, Russ & daughters and William Greenberg.”

“HELL YES to the blacks & whites, I would be so happy to get one of these baskets if you're looking for more friends. :D”

“I’m sad it ended up closing, but tbh we have way better bakeries now, especially with Breads having opened on 3rd (although my favorite black and whites are the ones from Kossars)”

“Pasticceria Rocco in the West Village is amazinggg! The best black & whites and rainbow cookies.”

“Best black and whites in the City”

“And they also make the best Black and White in the city.”

“Best I’ve tried so far: Culture Espresso and Levain for chocolate chip, the black and white cookie from Breads Bakery, all those wonderful monstrosities from Chip City, Italian cookies from Veniero’s”

“And their black and white cookies are also incredible! My favorites in the city for sure.”

“Caputo’s bakery has great bread’s, cakes, black and white cookies”

“We are visiting right now and bought a box of incredible small black and white cookies at Ess-A-Bagel on 3rd Avenue.”

“Excuse the crappy pictures but Meredith’s bread makes the best BW I have ever had. The chocolate half tastes more like a ganache than frosting.”

“The B/W cookies there are not really my style (Hot take, but I actually think Pick-a-bagel has the best B/W cookies)”

“ByClio has a really incredible black and white cookie (a bit crisper than traditional) with toasted soybean powder in it”

“I will never get over the black and white from Otto”

“Harlem has Lee Lee's who has hands down the best black and white cookie I've ever had.”

“For folks who like Levain, make sure to try the black and white cookies that are exclusive to the new Flatiron location. They're the best ones IMO, at least if you're really into the chocolate aspect.”

“I also love black and white cookies and found both Butterfield Market and Zabar’s had great ones.”

“Zaros still has a good black and white.”

“Their b&w cookies are good.”

“Enjoyed a black and white cookie (purely from seeing in a seinfeld episode) with no idea what it was actually supposed to be.”

“And their black and white!”

“Even if you aren’t a black and white cookie fan… I will ALWAYS recommend getting theirs. So damn good!”

“Black & White Cookie(2012): solid first bite. Felt like eating a lot of cheez its at once”

“Skip the black and white.”

“Will say that the black and whites here looked gorgeous but lacked flavor.”

“The OG Magnolia bakery is on Bleecker and the best b/w cookies are at orwashers, Russ & daughters and William Greenberg.”