Milkshake

“This may not be a popular opinion, mr softie are some of my all time favorite, nostalgia shakes!”

“S&P - also best tuna melts and milkshakes. Not cheap but the old New York diner vibe and the quality is worth it!”

“the milk shake is incredible as well.”

“Harlem Shake's, milk shakes and cheese fries are so damn good!”

“Best old fashion thick, or thin, or between milkshakes, and malts too.”

“It’s even better as a milkshake!! Absolute heaven on earth.”

“Ooh really love the one at Old John’s Luncheonette”

“I had the greatest milkshake at a Wawa . It was also b1g1. I think I only spent $3.”

“Burger Club also has top shakes!”

“Alamo draft house has great milkshakes”

“Weird rec but the Bill’s Bar and Burger under the Fidi Marriott makes some BANGIN shakes.”

“They are so good! Satisfyingly thick but easily suckable, sweet but not too sweet (the whipped cream on top is a key component), and tasting like the promised flavors, not just "cold" and "chemicals."”

“Moms Kitchen and Bar! Short walk from midtown west, great milkshakes and fun decor and menu overall”

“Morgenstern's has some really fascinating flavors that can be done as shakes, and special shakes as well.”

“Would also highly recommend milkshakes from Bareburger or anyone who sources their ice cream from Blue Marble.”

“Some more personal favorites include Revelie Luncheonette (amazing diner spot for milkshakes and burgers!)”

“Get the waffle fries and milkshake, cry when your bill is $30. Delicious, cute, very overpriced.”

“I actually really like the shake from Burger Joint”

“mama toos- in hell’s kitchen- solid shake with crazy topping!”

“Maybe some French fries, some cole slaw, maybe a milk shake or some cheesecake. Really simple and honestly quite tasty.”

“Place is great, reminds me of a 90s sitcom diner and the milkshakes and food are great.”

“Good shakes. A decent burger. And an iconic roast beef”

“Jacksonhole diner had a pretty good burger and shakes, was worth going to last time I had a rental to drop off at LGA”

“I like milkshakes from Chelsea market”

“I like their shakes a lot”

“Yup. Good milkshakes.”

“I think Ray’s candy shop in the east village does a good milkshake!”

“The milkshake was great too.”

“I enjoyed everything I tried, even the fries and milkshake (which was basically fries with ice cream).”

“Diner 24 (on 22nd and 3rd ave) has some insanely decked out milkshakes, they were pretty good too”