Milkshake

“The collard sandwich and the date shake are two of my favorite things I’ve eaten.”

“This may not be a popular opinion, mr softie are some of my all time favorite, nostalgia shakes!”

“I get their black and white milkshake with malt added - it’s incredible.”

“S&P - also best tuna melts and milkshakes. Not cheap but the old New York diner vibe and the quality is worth it!”

“Burger Club also has top shakes!”

“Harlem Shake's, milk shakes and cheese fries are so damn good!”

“Best old fashion thick, or thin, or between milkshakes, and malts too.”

“I love the Black & White shake at Tom's Restaurant in Morningside Heights (The most photographed restaurant in history).”

“Roll n Roaster has my favorite vanilla milkshake in the world.”

“It’s even better as a milkshake!! Absolute heaven on earth.”

“The gelato milkshakes they make here are so fucking good.”

“Ooh really love the one at Old John’s Luncheonette”

“I had the greatest milkshake at a Wawa . It was also b1g1. I think I only spent $3.”

“Alamo draft house has great milkshakes”

“Brgr their blueberry milkshakes 😭🥵😋”

“Weird rec but the Bill’s Bar and Burger under the Fidi Marriott makes some BANGIN shakes.”

“They are so good! Satisfyingly thick but easily suckable, sweet but not too sweet (the whipped cream on top is a key component), and tasting like the promised flavors, not just "cold" and "chemicals."”

“Would also highly recommend milkshakes from Bareburger or anyone who sources their ice cream from Blue Marble.”

“I got the Applewood smoked bacon burger as a double,fries , Louie sauce ,and a cookie & cream milkshake (not pictured). I give everything a 9/10 .”

“Morgenstern's has some really fascinating flavors that can be done as shakes, and special shakes as well.”

“The hazelnut chocolate milkshake is awesome”

“I’ve had great chocolate milkshakes recently at Brooklyn Diner near Carnegie Hall and Schnippers.”

“Some more personal favorites include Revelie Luncheonette (amazing diner spot for milkshakes and burgers!)”

“I’ve had great chocolate milkshakes recently at Brooklyn Diner near Carnegie Hall and Schnippers.”

“Get the waffle fries and milkshake, cry when your bill is $30. Delicious, cute, very overpriced.”

“I picked up a chocolate and espresso milkshake on another day, which was great and they also have Mexican coke which I love.”

“Dumont burger has amazing boozy shakes, great burgers and fried pickles”

“I did enjoy Burger By Day's milkshake in chinatown (they had a green tea one).”