Burger Club — FoodNYC

What Reddit says35

View all

in:Burger Club in Astoria Queens4 pts
replying to u/BourgeoisieInNYC: How was it? Last time we were there it was pretty empty and one of our burgers looked sus. Like it was still pink when we asked for medium well. The person who ate it ended up in the bathroom all night. But it used to be one of our most frequented spot.
“the smash burger was low key undercooked (not sure how that’s possible) and the bun was soaked through. Used to be my favorite burger spot in Astoria but they’ve been hit or miss at best lately.”
H3
in:What's your "go-to" casual neighborhood spot?2 pts
“Best burger in the neighborhood, big ass salads served in a huge bowl, the waffle fries and onion rings rule, staff is super attentive and friendly. All around perfect casual neighborhood spot.”
H3
in:Burger Club in Astoria Queens1 pts
“one of our burgers looked sus. Like it was still pink when we asked for medium well. The person who ate it ended up in the bathroom all night.”
H3
in:What's the best low-key burger in NYC? Looking for something that doesn't make the typical "top burgers" lists16 pts
“burger club is super low key but good as hell and way less expensive than most other burger places.”
H2
in:What's the best low-key burger in NYC? Looking for something that doesn't make the typical "top burgers" lists12 pts
replying to u/mikemuscalaGOAT: I like the bonnies burger in park slope
“I think Burger Club in Astoria has some of the best burgers as well.”
H2
in:Burger Club in Astoria Queens8 pts
“Waffle Fries and Smash Burgers are the best here”
H2
in:Best chocolate milkshakes in NYC?8 pts
“There is a great banana chocolate milkshake at Burger Club in Astoria if you are ever in the area!”
H2
in:What’s your neighborhood spot that is good, maybe just OK, but you love it so much?6 pts
“Burger Club in Astoria is so damn good. The food is excellent, reasonably priced, and super consistent”
H2
in:Help me pick my one burger and fries for the year4 pts
replying to u/charcoalist: Donovan's in Woodside if you don't mind venturing into the boroughs. It's really not that far from midtown and checks all of your boxes. Add some Coleman's mustard to it. Donovan's is also my personal favorite, as someone who's probably a bit too obsessed with burgers. Red Hook Tavern was probably the overall best in the city that I've had, but it is a very simple burger. I was disappointed with Emily's burger. Super long wait and lots of gristle in the meat. The flavor was otherwise unremarkable. Loved the burger at Nowon. Haven't been to Au Cheval but it's on my list. Bareburger sucks, sorry you ate there lol. Minetta's Tavern was also a let down for me, definitely not worth the price. The burger was good, but for that aged meat patty, Red Hook Tavern was better. The Peter Luger's burger is also excellent, and is what the Red Hook Tavern based their burger on.
“The burgers are tasty and they have hand-cut fries, thicker than I personally like, but perfectly cooked, and great dipping sauces.”
H2
in:Finally tried a Smash Burger3 pts
replying to u/thecakeisalie9: I see you are in Astoria, you have to try Petey’s burger in LIC. Best burger I ever had.
“Burger Clubs double smash is my favorite if you haven’t tried that”
H2
in:places with good food and good milkshakes? 2 pts
replying to u/donut_butt: Maybe I’ve had bad luck at Moms, but if I’m in that area, I’d be happier going to Burger Club or Peteys instead.
“Burger Club also has top shakes!”
H2
in:Anyone ever been to Bare Burger?2 pts
“Burger Club has the best burgers in Astoria.”
H2

See all 35 mentions