“The pastrami at S&P (fka Eisenberg's) is on par with Katz's but their sandwiches are a little smaller and more manageable. (And cheaper.)”
H3
9.2/10American
AI-generated summary
Get the . People order it monthly and say it never changes. The and the are the other two picks, and the is worth saving room for. It's an old lunch counter and there's a line at lunch, so go after it dies down.
“The pastrami at S&P (fka Eisenberg's) is on par with Katz's but their sandwiches are a little smaller and more manageable. (And cheaper.)”
H3
“A great alternative to Katz is S&P Lunch. Similar old school NYC Jewish vibe but fewer tourists and more locals. Both places have great pastrami, tho S&P’s is more modest. S&P has a more extensive menu.”
H3
“Tuna melt's good but the patty melt at S&P has that crispy rye that actually holds up to the meat and cheese without getting soggy like half the melts in this city do.”
H3
“The food was very very ordinary, bordering on Denny's quality.”
H3
“Tuna Melt and French Fries from S&P Lunch - as good as it gets”
H2
“Not pictured is the rugelach and carrot cake which are also divine. I've only been once before and got the Lil Shonda before which was equally as good as the patty melt imo.”
H2
“S&P’s BLT is usually a 10/10 taste 7/10 looker, but today they served me this beauty”
H2
“S&P burger at Madison square park is good for $9.”
H2
“S&P has great pastrami!”
H2
“S&P for tuna melt”
H2
“Tuna melt is elite”
H2
“love that sandwich”
H2