Pizza

“Get the Sicilian and or the Upside Down Sicilian, they are amazing!”

“Spumoni gardens best Sicilian ever.”

“Favorite pizza in the city is the Sicilian slice at L&B”

“Their Sicilian and grandma slices are insane”

“Manhattan: favorite pie was Rubirosa and favorite slice was mama’s too (for Sicilian) or stretch (sell slices until 4 or 5pm I forget)”

“Sicilian is amazing if you either order a whole pizza or get a fresh slice right as the place opens, but has a huge quality drop if you get a slice that's been reheated.”

“SLICEHAUS have the best Sicilian in NYC right now! Hands up !”

“I’ve hit just about every major slice in my ten years in the city but the Rosario’s Sicilian knocks me out every time, it’s magical”

“Mano’s is also worth going to ridgewood before your rolos dinner and trying a slice of pizza - i love their manopella or their sicilian (light and incredibly crunchy/chewy)”

“Norms Pizza (vodka sauce and Sicilian are tops)”

“For Sicilian, Village Square is excellent”

“I've lived in NYC my whole life and was never crazy about pizza until I had the sicilian from Pizza Wagon. It's the first pizza I've actually craved.”

“I had both their regular slice and their Sicilian, both great but I think the latter is even better.”

“Did you get the Sicilian? I still think those are great.”

“I love Lo Duca for their plain and sicilian, these are pushing it.”

“My local go-to is a sicilian or sausage & sage slice from F&F in Carroll Gardens.”

“Totally agree, I first had it years ago, and I really did like the Sicilian (buddy I was with said circle pie is sub par so I’ve never had it), but a few months ago the office had it brought in, the sauce was so sweet.”

“There’s pizza for the unadventurous, great Sicilian for everyone else, and a killer wine selection.”

“Carmines on graham ave makes some good sicilian slices”

“Crust, sauce was perfect on the two regular slices. Flavor and crust was very good on the sicilian but it was a bit overcooked to my taste when it came to the crust. Too charred and inedibly hard but otherwise great. 9.5/10”

“If you go there expecting a Sicilian slice, it's great.”

“Ace’s Pizza just opened in Rockefeller Center and does a good Sicilian as well (original location in Brooklyn). Their crust is lighter/fluffier than Prince St.”

“I know it’s a chain but Made in NY has some good Sicilian”

“Mimi’s Pizza (3rd and 86th) has a solid Sicilian slice.”

“Philomenas - I like the Sicilians more than their regular slices which sometimes are a bit tough”

“Get any Sicilian from pizza joints like Gravesend, My Little Pizzeria, J’s, Nolita, and others I can recommend if you lemme know what part of the city you’re looking. These are all doughy and delicious”

“Get any Sicilian from pizza joints like Gravesend, My Little Pizzeria, J’s, Nolita, and others I can recommend if you lemme know what part of the city you’re looking. These are all doughy and delicious”

“It may not have the pedigree of the others, but I’ve always sworn by Rose’s Sicilian red slice at Penn Station”

“Gotham pizza makes a non traditional Sicilian which sounds like what you’re describing. Get a fresh pie instead of a slice — it’s super fluffy and not crispy.”

“Buffalo, NY. Or try East village pizza but it’s pretty much Sicilian there.”