Scarr's Pizza — FoodNYC

What Reddit says974

View all

postRIP to Scarr’s 🫡212 pts
“I went to Scarr’s last night and sadly confirmed that its quality has totally fallen off.”
H3
in:Who is your go to pizza place in nyc?10 pts
replying to u/sk1990: It’s very good, but also definitely overrated.
“Most overrated pie ever. I recently went in on a Thursday at 5pm and waited in 25 min just to get to the register.”
H3
in:Is Scarr's still good? What pizza is the best in the LES?9 pts
“Scarr’s new spot sucks. It’s dirty. They play music so loud you can’t talk, the bathroom door is always broken, the service is slow as fuck and their whole pizzas are mid at best.”
H3
in:RIP to Scarr’s 🫡5 pts
replying to u/Loofah1: I went last night, too. Their system for slices is crazily inefficient: customer dithers over what to order, customer orders and pays, next person waits until their slices are heated and served, repeat. You can sit at the bar after (if you’re just ordering slices), but the bartender goes AWOL frequently. Pizza was 3/5.
“My slices were also a little too burnt when I got them; I don’t mind some char but I’m not going to eat a fully black bubble of overcooked crust.”
H3
in:What is the most overrated or overpriced piece of pizza you’ve had?4 pts
“I was severely disappointed. The pizza was basically a thin sheet of paper that was flopping over from the amount of grease on it.”
H3
in:Johnny’s Pizza LES3 pts
replying to u/gucci_pucci: Please share your opinion on Scarrs so I can accurately weigh your opinion on Johnny’s.
“Scarrs is good fresh but their signature taste comes from letting the pizza sit for extended times at room temp to go stale- before they reheat it and serve it.”
H3
in:How is Ceres pizza?3 pts
replying to u/bedofhoses: No one seems to be mentioning Scarrs. That is the best slice I have had.
“Because it fell off years ago at this point. In 2015 it was really something interesting, not just the pizza but the vibe. But the more popular it got, the less consistent it was, and then the workers act like weed shop burnouts instead of a pizziolo with pride.”
H3
in:Why does Scarrs insist on serving stale pizza?3 pts
“both times they didn’t properly reheat their slices. The flavor was great but we got lukewarm slices that flopped all over the place.”
H3
in:Is Scarr's still good? What pizza is the best in the LES?3 pts
“it was some of the worst pizza Ive tried in this city. Greasy, spongy, sloppy, flimsy and incredibly average flavors.”
H3
in:Popular/highly rated restaurants you’ve been disappointed by?2 pts
replying to u/Few-Restaurant7922: Scarr’s Pizza
“THE ABSOLUTE WORST PIZZA SHOP IN THE CITY. I fuckin’ hate their pizza and service at Scarrs. Overpriced, salty pizza with a side of a nasty attitude.”
H3
in:Favorite Pizza in NYC_2 pts
replying to u/meliful: Scarr’s
“Was there this past weekend. Very thin but strangely tough and chewy. Our jaws got tired from eating a plain cheese slice”
H3
in:The 22 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now2 pts
replying to u/Lyin-Don: No Scarrs. Good.
“I went to Scarr’s last time we were down there and was SO underwhelmed. The pizza was nothing special”
H3

See all 974 mentions