Fish

“Before I tried the tuna melt at Agi’s Counter, this one was the best I’ve ever had (for a few days, haha). The portion was massive and the bread was soooo buttery.”

“Tuna Melt and French Fries from S&P Lunch - as good as it gets”

“The Sephardi wrap and tuna melt are to die for”

“Came here to say this - Agi's tuna melt FTW!”

“Not sure if it's the absolute best one, but Lexington Candy Shop's version is pretty killer, and eating there feels like walking into a time portal to the 1940s. Highly recommended.”

“I may get downvoted for this but I freaking love Friedmans tuna melt. Buttery rye bread, the perfect but not”

“Sadelle’s makes the best tuna melt I’ve ever had (it’s small and pretty expensive though).”

“Stop!!! The schnippers on Lex is the best. The tuna melts are unreal”

“Just had a great tuna melt at Old John’s Diner.”

“Fanellis isn’t the most amazing food but I like to have a solo tuna melt and beer there after later nights at work”

“tuna melt from Kossar’s is great!”

“Russ and daughters cafe has a very strong tuna melt”

“Agis, Golden Diner, B&H dairy, K’Far or S&P lunch for Tuna melt”

“Great chicken fingers, great fries, great tuna melt.”

“Get the little tuna melts and a glass of wine at baby sips”

“B&H Dairy has the best tuna melt on challah”

“Hot fish or tuna melt from the commodore”

“shoutouts to katz’s corn beef, 4 charles’ french dip, salt’s hank’s french dip, mama’s too’s chicken alla vodka, court street grocers’ italian combo and salty lunch lady’s tuna melt”

“Like - you've never had bacon and pancakes or a tuna melt before.”

“Help, I am obsessed with this sandwich. I want to recreate it at home — what is the secret? Any idea what kind of tuna they use? To me, it is not fishy at all and tastes more like chicken salad.”