Cocktail

“Best Mezcal old fashioned, regular old fashioned, and martini I have ever had in my life.”

“Also iirc one of the best and most unique old fashioneds I've ever had! That alone is worth a visit.”

“They have my favorite old fashioned that I’ve had in the city”

“The full fat old fashioned and sticky toffee pudding were excellent, would definitely get again.”

“I love Minetta Tavern, they make great old fashions.”

“Imo, the appetizers and cocktails. They have some great old fashioned ones.”

“I had an old fashioned, espresso Martini and some mix red wine cocktail. They were all great.”

“The steaks are great, the burgers and great, and they make a great old fashioned.”

“Same for their old fashioneds!”

“Rye in Williamsburg. The old fashioned!”

“Recommend the old fashion.”

“This. I always order an old fashioned every where I go, and when I did at atomix, the guy told me they use smoked tea to mimic the flavor of whiskey and that’s when I was won over”

“Hotel bars are usually a bit more lowkey, and any decent one should be able to make you a good old fashioned. Beekman comes to mind.”

“Same for drinks - classic old fashioned for 35$ on the menu.. wtf? Happy to spend a lot of money on food but is there an explanation why this is not at all mentioned critically other than people don’t seem to care at all ?”

“Lovely’s old fashioned - sit at the counter and forget about the world for half hour”

“It’s a very small Japanese jazz bar.Dishes are smaller Japanese street foods, imported Japanese beers & Japanese whiskey, & classic cocktails (e.g. old fashions, martinis, etc.) it’s also very affordable.”

“Amor y Amargo (my personal favorite cocktail bar, 'strong stirred' describes what I like and what they tend to make) always have classic cocktails (negroni/old fashioned/manhattan type things) on the menu.”

“They have a killer happy hour “Adult Happy Meal” (a solid burger & a cocktail like an old fashioned or martini) for like $35 and then you can have another drink upstairs in their speakeasy.”

“They had a decent old fashioned too”

“I didn't love the cocktails, i got the old fashioned and it was very smokey.”

“Probably the best view in the city but I also had the worst Old Fashioned there in my life.”