“Service was impeccable, I’ve never experienced such great hospitality. food was excellent and I was full af after.”
H3
8.0/10American
AI-generated summary
Sit in the tavern room and get the . People call it one of the best in the city, though $35 for a is the common gripe. Service comes up more than any dish, warm and precise even at the bar. In the dining room the tasting menu splits people. Starters and desserts land, but regulars say the entrees can be bland for the price.
“Service was impeccable, I’ve never experienced such great hospitality. food was excellent and I was full af after.”
H3
“I can honestly say this was the best burger of my life. The juiciness, the flavor, the slight sweetness—for such a simple burger with just three ingredients, it was absolutely incredible!”
H3
“Overall Rating - 4/5; My Michelin Rating - 2*; Would I Recommend - Absolutely! This restaurant is all about putting great ingredients and good flavor combinations on the plate, and they certainly succeed at that!”
H3
“Hubs and I went here to celebrate our anniversary and it was a great experience. The butternut squash lasagna with brown butter and picked peppers was the standout dish for me (left on pic 2), but all of it was delicious, even the rolls they brought out between courses.”
H3
“They brought the wrong wine for 3 of the 5 courses. They would pour it, then a few minutes later come over with an apology and a new glass with the correct pairing. Not complaining since hey free wine, but certainly didn’t expect that many errors.”
H3
“The onion bread they give you is incredible. Burger is great but can go more interesting for first time.”
H3
“I had the worst experience at Gramercy Tavern. We were ignored for the first 20 minutes then waiters came flying in and processed us through the whole experience with cold, brutal efficiency.”
H3
“From start to finish just a sublime experience.”
H3
“the food is solid, but it’s not some world changing culinary experience”
H3
“Ah, my favorite as well. Been going since.... 2012 I think. Love their tasting menu.”
H3
“I was just there and was a bit disappointed. The portion sizes were too small for a $175, 5 course tasting with multiple vegan items.”
H3
“Love Gramercy Tavern! They have always put a premium on service, and to me, it’s exactly the experience I want in a high-end restaurant; professional, attentive without being hovering, and warm and welcoming.”
H3