Cake

“The eclair, cannoli, pignoli, strawberry shortcake, I mean I’ve had a lot of things from there and they’ve all been best of the best, I legitimately would love to know what’s better?”

“I’ll add from steakhouses in the order of my favorites- Strawberry Shortcake from Smith and Wollensky, butter cake from Del Frisco’s Double Eagle, carrot cake from Keen’s, and the 24 layer chocolate cake from Strip House.”

“i just ordered a whole strawberry shortcake for my birthday. one of the best!”

“ok so my favorite cake ever is the milk bar strawberry shortcake. it is limited edition and they don't offer it every year so i would recommend that (again). >D”

“I can only vouch for the strawberry shortcake but it is top tier; not too sweet, light and airy, super fresh.”

“I assume the menu changes often, but when I went it was just really refined versions of classic favourites - strawberry shortcake, boeuf bourgignon, lobster and burrata, that sort of stuff - prepared perfectly.”

“Doesn't matter the flavor they're all great but I'd get strawberry shortcake.”

“Little Cupcake Bakeshop: my favorite is their Brooklyn blackout, strawberry shortcake, or dreaming princess.”

“Mia's Bakery shocks me with it's quality every damn time. We got our wedding cake from there, the Strawberry Shortcake. Beat out a bunch of 'expensive wedding options' we were looking at.”

“Martha's is definitely very so-so overall, but I really enjoyed their strawberry shortcake.”

“I love the strawberry shortcake at Tony’s di Napoli - but it’s not a classic since it has ice cream!”

“Patisserie Fouet’s strawberry shortcake is delicious.”

“Oasis Cafe in Queens had an amazing strawberry shortcake that I got for my girlfriend. We still think about it to this day.”

“Lady M does a damn good strawberry shortcake. But it’s the opposite of old timey rustic.”

“I really like the strawberry shortcake at Balthazar”

“Petit Chou does cakes upon request, totally worth it, really like their strawberry shortcake”

“It was like a take on strawberry shortcake and it was so good!”

“Also tried the Tavern's own summer ale and had the best espresso martini I've tasted!! Oh yeah and the strawberry shortcake.”

“Cousin John's in Park Slope does a good strawberry shortcake. They also sell slices.”

“In the past few months I’ve been able to snag their strawberry shortcake and katsu sando once or twice, but once they sell out they’re out so go early!”

“Very old school. Has a strawberry shortcake that my family has been getting for birthdays for decades.”

“A decent runner up is Ferrara in Little Italy.”