Cake

“Little Cupcake Bake Shop has my favorite cake slices.”

“Red Gate Bakery; everything is great (and they have the best cake slice)”

“This is a honest recommendation -tou le jours is the best. If you don’t believe it, seamless the slice and try it! Kids stove it and it’s super light”

“I second Chloe, it’s incredible.. the mac n cheese and cake slices are my favs there!”

“The cinnamon roll is a popular item but I found it overrated compared to their cakes which are incredible (honey, carrot, chocolate, PB&J, can’t go wrong).”

“Claud is honest to god my favorite slice of cake in the city. I think it's a shame if the slice OP got was dry, but my personal experience with their cakes has been very moist.”

“Lots of local sweets featured and their cake slices are the best”

“For something decadent, the giant slice at Maison Pickle.”

“If I recall correctly, the cake slices were actually pretty good, the rainbow cookies were middle-of-the-road, and the faux cronuts were a bit stale.”

“Their cakes/ slices are great!”

“I've liked other desserts there a lot more (i.e. cake slice, a chocolate peanut butter mousse that was incredible), so don't automatically choose the BA if something else sounds more appealing”

“Wegmans also sometimes carries really good slices.”

“I think the cake slices are the way to go, very satisfying and rich.”

“Still a damn good slice of cake!”

“The cake slices are large so bring a friend but I love how balanced they are.”

“I really really like their cake slices. It was a once a year special treat when I worked in the area.”

“I've never had a stale slice, btw.”

“I like Georgia diner in queens a lot very solid staff and great selection for cake.”

“Maybe Paris Baguette if it has to be a chain? Decent, fluffy, not too sweet, and they’re everywhere nowadays.”

“Otherwise huge fan of Davey’s ice cream cake, Veniero’s Oreo cheesecake and rainbow cookies, Little Cupcake Bake Shop, and yes Magnolia’s cupcakes and cake slices (but mostly the Key Lime icebox bar).”