Peppino's — all mentions

in:Best Eats in Bay Ridge?13 pts
“Peppino's is the best pizza in the neighborhood, but it's whole pies only.”
H2
in:Best cheesesteak in NYC?6 pts
“the best cheesesteak here is the cheesesteak hoagie from Peppino’s in Brooklyn. It’s not exactly like from Philly but it’s its own awesome thing.”
H2
in:Best Italian Heros?6 pts
“Peppinos in Park slope brooklyn serves up amazing meatball, chicken parm and grilled chicken caprese hero's on their homemade pizza dough bread!”
H2
in:Most Underhyped Pizzas in NYC4 pts
“The margarita pie from Peppino’s is everything.”
H2
in:Best Italian Heros?2 pts
replying to u/cawfytawk: Peppinos in Park slope brooklyn serves up amazing meatball, chicken parm and grilled chicken caprese hero's on their homemade pizza dough bread!
“Don’t sleep on the cheesesteak hoagie there either”
H2
in:What’s your fave Pizza spot in NYC?2 pts
“Whole pies: Peppino's in Bay Ridge”
H2
in:Best pasta in Brooklyn?1 pts
“Peppinos has fire pasta, also amazing brick oven pizza too”
H2
in:Best Italian Heros?1 pts
replying to u/thenumbersthenumbers: Don’t sleep on the cheesesteak hoagie there either
“My go-to is the Special Cheesesteak with mushrooms and red peppers!”
H2
in:Best Italian Heros?1 pts
replying to u/Flaste: They will also make the sandwich with vodka sauce if you ask!
“I love their house sauce and they're always super accommodating if you ask for extra sauce (I'm a dipper!)”
H2
in:Recommendations for the best NY Style Pizza in under an hour1 pts
“Completely underrated.”
H2
in:Italian American Spots1 pts
replying to u/AdeGamisou2020: Gino's hasn't been good in quite some time. Peppino's is ok. For Bay Ridge there are much better options depending on how much you want to spend and what your want to eat. I'm partial to Piccante and Amuni, if you're looking for more upscale there's Terina. And while I'm not the biggest fan and think it's a bit overrated people really seem to love Brooklyn Roots. And if you want nearby, Il Colosseo has good old school Italian as does Ortobello.
“i had a great pizza and a few apps at peppinos.”
H2
in:Favorite Pizza in NYC?7 pts
“Peppino’s in Bay Ridge, Julianna’s, John’s of Bleecker Street, L&B, Bleecker Street, Scarr’s, Unregular and Joe’s (which is absolutely top-tier)”
H1
in:Favorite pizza spot, most underrated pizza spot, and worst pizza you’ve had (no national chains)5 pts
“Peppino’s, Del Mar, underground pizza”
H1
in:Italian American Spots4 pts
“Peppino's is ok.”
H1
in:Pizza Ratings from a first timer in NYC (2024)3 pts
replying to u/DinerEnBlanc: As a lifelong Brooklynite who grew up near Luigi's and at their pizza growing up, WTF? lol
“Peppinos, giuseppinas, and DOP are all better”
H1
in:Most Underhyped Pizzas in NYC3 pts
“Wheated, Giuseppina’s, Peppino’s”
H1
in:Brooklyn Restaurants for Out of Towners!2 pts
“Peppinos, Thai Farm Kitchen, Jalsa.”
H1
in:Best cheesesteak in NYC?2 pts
replying to u/thenumbersthenumbers: I’m orig from Philly. Sorry to say it but all the Federoff’s stans don’t know shit. It’s like ChatGPT created a bad amalgamation of what it thought a Philly cheesesteak actually was. Not only is it overly salty and kinda bad… it costs more than a large pizza. But hot take: the best cheesesteak here is the cheesesteak hoagie from Peppino’s in Brooklyn. It’s not exactly like from Philly but it’s its own awesome thing. Trust me.
“Peppino’s fucking rocks”
H1
in:Been in NYC for 2 years and have been to 250 restaurants. Will be leaving in a week and thought I'd share my list.2 pts
replying to u/studmuffffffin: Ayat. For pizza I liked pizza wagon, but mostly because it was the closest. Also, the halal cart on 86th and 5th next to the bank.
“Down there, it's got to be Peppino's on 3rd ave. Decisively.”
H1
in:Pizza Wagon Bayridge2 pts
replying to u/xeothought: I somewhat recently tried both ... and I prefer Manchini's. Don't get me wrong, they're both great. But Manchini's is really one of the top regular slices in the city imo.
“Luliano's and Peppino's are two more that I'm shocked I don't hear more people talk about.”
H1
in:Most Underhyped Pizzas in NYC2 pts
replying to u/JayMoots: The margarita pie from Peppino’s is everything. Or the pepperoni square from Nino’s, which rivals Prince Street.
“This right here Peppinos is so slept on”
H1
in:Most Underhyped Pizzas in NYC2 pts
“Peppino’s in Bay Ridge”
H1
in:Cheese steaks2 pts
“Peppino’s gives it a run for it’s money.”
H1
in:Italian American Spots2 pts
replying to u/Hot-Takes-101: solid, thank you. i’ll add to the list. we do annual trips to bayridge to eat. not going to lie, i had a great pizza and a few apps at peppinos.
“They're not bad but they're also nothing special.”
H1
in:What’s the best cheesesteak I can get here?1 pts
“peppinos in South Brooklyn has been a sleeper for years.”
H1
in:Favorite sit-in restaurant only pizza spots for whole pies?1 pts
“Best hidden gem pizza spot in the city.”
H1