Gertie — all mentions

in:What is a restaurant that is bad (truly poor experience), but has 1 amazing dish? and what is that dish?2 pts
replying to u/Maleficent_Guide_727: Gertie’s in Williamsburg. Y’all can say what you’d like, but everything I’ve gotten there has been mid to inedible, but their matzo ball soup is almost always excellent. The pastries are usually good too.
“the egg sandwich was tepid and chewy, the hash made my girl sick. Never again with Gerties, we use it as a joke suggestion when no one can pick a breakfast spot lmao”
H3
in:Best Bagels/breakfast near Barclays? My wife put me on a mission and I cannot fail2 pts
“Gerties is fine for bagels, but their everything bagel is over-everythinged and some of their sandwich and spread options are incredibly overly salty.”
H3
in:What is a restaurant that is bad (truly poor experience), but has 1 amazing dish? and what is that dish?21 pts
“everything I’ve gotten there has been mid to inedible, but their matzo ball soup is almost always excellent. The pastries are usually good too.”
H2
in:What is a restaurant that is bad (truly poor experience), but has 1 amazing dish? and what is that dish?6 pts
replying to u/Maleficent_Guide_727: Gertie’s in Williamsburg. Y’all can say what you’d like, but everything I’ve gotten there has been mid to inedible, but their matzo ball soup is almost always excellent. The pastries are usually good too.
“Nah, I love Gertie. Their veggie chopped cheese is lowkey fire and their german potato salad fries are crazy”
H2
in:Recs in east Williamsburg-ish?3 pts
“GERTIE is a Jewish brunch spot with a colorful & comfortable atmosphere and delicious bagel sandwiches.”
H2
in:Best Bagels/breakfast near Barclays? My wife put me on a mission and I cannot fail3 pts
“The Gertie bagel is smaller, chewy and dense, which is more of a classic NY bagel.”
H2
in:The Great Nosh - a great waste of money - would not recommend3 pts
replying to u/Garconavecunreve: I really like the collaboration concept; whilst I understand the organisers need/ interest to make money from tickets I agree that $40 is waaay overpriced The individual items themselves I found very mixed tbh - I was pretty exited for the gertie and kabawa crossover but felt super letdown, on the other hand the oneg Babka, the kfar and sailor borek were great. The ops potato pie was really good too but could have just been a standard menu choice
“Gertie's bagel was absolutely amazing as it normally is”
H2
in:Best Bagels/breakfast near Barclays? My wife put me on a mission and I cannot fail0 pts
replying to u/CatoTheMiddleAged: Gertie is good but it’s still not Bagel Hole.
“Agree (grew up in park slope, now live in prospect heights). But it's still in the same style of bagel as bagel hole, which is inherently better than the fat doughy bagel pub transplant bagel”
H2
in:Your favourite spots? 3 days in NYC. 18 pts
“Four Horsemen and Gertie are also good near there.”
H1
in:The Great Nosh - a great waste of money - would not recommend9 pts
“felt super letdown”
H1
in:Best Bagels/breakfast near Barclays? My wife put me on a mission and I cannot fail5 pts
“I'd suggest GERTIE -- about a 12 minute walk from Barclays. They have the best bagel this side of Flatbush avenue.”
H1
in:Best outdoor dining patios?4 pts
“Gertie”
H1
in:Jewish Food crawl3 pts
“Not Manhattan but: Onegs bakery, Gertrude’s, Gerties”
H1
in:Which places have become part of your regular rotation the past year?3 pts
“Gertrude’s and gerties”
H1
in:NYC Bagel shops with great coffee? Please help. I’ve checked out most of them.3 pts
“Only place I know of where both applies is Gerties in Brooklyn”
H1
in:Best fried chicken cutlet2 pts
“Gertie”
H1
in:Best Bagels/breakfast near Barclays? My wife put me on a mission and I cannot fail2 pts
replying to u/Goldzinger: Depends on what "close to Barclays" means. The masses who are telling you to go to Bagel Pub are wrong. Bagel Pub is incredibly mid. Bergen Bagels also pretty mid. I'd suggest GERTIE -- about a 12 minute walk from Barclays. They have the best bagel this side of Flatbush avenue. Others have also suggested Shelsky's, I'd say that's also a great choice, especially if you're looking to get the works (fish, etc) on your bagel.
“Gertie is good but it’s still not Bagel Hole.”
H1
in:Good Cafe near Barclays? Bonus for tea/ breakfast food selection2 pts
“Gertie”
H1
in:Best Latkes in the city?1 pts
“Gertie”
H1
in:Restaurant regrets... I've had a few1 pts
“Balthazar, Rezdora, Gallagher's, Edith's, Gertie”
H1
in:Bialys1 pts
“Gertie in Prospect Heights”
H1
in:Friday Lunch in Prospect Heights/Crown Heights/Park Slope1 pts
“Agi's Counter, Gertie, Cafe Mado, Lincoln Station”
H1
in:What's your favorite bakery?1 pts
“Gerties”
H1
in:My friends and I need recs for a Brooklyn food tour1 pts
“Gerties, l imprimerie, welcome home bakery and win son”
H1
in:Best Bagels/breakfast near Barclays? My wife put me on a mission and I cannot fail1 pts
“Gerties”
H1
in:Best new restaurants/coffee shops/bakeries opened in last 8 months?1 pts
“Gertie”
H1
in:Best Bagels/breakfast near Barclays? My wife put me on a mission and I cannot fail0 pts
“gertie”
H1