Scalini Fedeli

All 26 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:Best experiential/wow meals you've had in NYC?1 pts
“Amazed at the quality for the price point ($89 for 5 course prix fixe). Beautiful space, super attentive but not overbearing service”
H3
in:Best upscale/fine dining value meals?1 pts
“Five courses for under $100 in a beautiful space with excellent service and a great wine selection. Classic Italian.”
H3
postA few days in NYC5 pts
“Simple Italian menu, food was great and service was nice also. It was quiet when we went and had a lot of attentive behavior from the manager. It is a reasonably priced restaurant for being so high end, but the wine list may kill you on price - 7.5/10”
H2
in:Lunch in TriBeCa3 pts
replying to u/mamapello: Scalini fedelli
“I love this place so much. One of the first nicer restaurants I went to in New York 15 years ago and it is still a great spot to go to for a quiet meal.”
H2
in:Scalini Fedeli or Locanda Verde2 pts
“Scalini Fedeli would be my vote given you are looking for quieter / romantic - the food is also excellent, better service too vs Locanda. Both great Tribeca staples.”
H2
in:Suggestions Italian restaurant 1 pts
replying to u/Glaucoma_suspect: Scalini Fedeli
“Plus 1. Delicious and easy to get a res. Romantic vibe”
H2
in:Recommendation for visitor for a 'classic' experience?1 pts
“No live music, but this has been one of my best restaurant experiences in NYC. It's way downtown but worth the ride. Classy, classic interior:”
H2
in:Italian below 23rd street with great food, not noisy with round tables1 pts
“Pretty sure Scalini Fedeli (underrated IMO) has some round tables!”
H2
in:Scalini Fedeli1 pts
“For mains, he heavily recommended the artic char”
H2
in:Scalini Fedeli1 pts
“I personally thought it was amazing! Lovely service, great food, cool vibes.”
H2
in:Italian restaurant recommendations?7 pts
“Upscale old school. Really nice experience and a beautiful room as well.”
H1
in:Suggestions Italian restaurant 6 pts
“Scalini Fedeli”
H1
in:Recommendations for genuinely underrated nice-ish restaurants in Manhattan. Leaning towards authentic Italian but open to others! (No steakhouses, sorry)5 pts
“A nice quiet place but maybe over budget Scalini Fedeli”
H1
in:Italian restaurant recommendations?4 pts
“Scalini Fedeli”
H1
in:What was your worst dining experience in NYC?4 pts
“The restaurant in that spot now, Scalini Fedeli, is excellent Tuscan that’s very accommodating and IMO underloved.”
H1
in:30th Birthday Dinner Recommendations3 pts
“I enjoyed an incredible dining experience at Scalini Fedeli in Tribeca. The service was astounding and they made you feel very special.”
H1
in:Prix Fixe Italian/Seafood Dinner in NYC3 pts
“It’s a throwback in the best way possible.”
H1
in:What is your favorite romantic restaurant in manhattan?3 pts
“Scalini Fedeli”
H1
in:Looking for tasty business dinner sit down in FiDi/TriBeCa.1 pts
“Scalini Fedeli”
H1
in:Suggestions Italian restaurant 1 pts
replying to u/Glaucoma_suspect: Scalini Fedeli
“Best date I’ve ever been on was there”
H1
in:My mom on a wednesday- "I'm coming to visit Saturday! Can you get a 5 person reservation for a cute little italian restaurant in west village?"☠️1 pts
“I enjoyed Scalini Fedeli, not on the current buzz list and maybe a little pricey, but have been a few times and enjoyed.”
H1
in:Mid-priced tasting menu or prix fixe menus with vegetarian and meat options?1 pts
“Scalini Fedeli”
H1
in:Best Italian in the city?1 pts
“Scalini Fedeli in Tribeca is great as well.”
H1
in:Help Me Choose a Dinner Spot for the Night Before I Propose1 pts
“Scalini Fedeli is awesome and where I went before I proposed. It’s excellent but very old school Italian.”
H1
in:What are some good Italian restaurants to take 7 midwestern dudes (all in their 60s) who have never been to NYC?1 pts
“Less current and more under the radar Wildcard options: Brooklyn Roots Michaels of Brooklyn Ginos Scalini Fedeli”
H1
in:Scalini Fedeli1 pts
“Great experience for anniversary”
H1