Adrienne's Pizzabar

6.8/10Italian

AI-generated summary

People come for the grandma style square pie, thick and doughy, not New York style. Sitting outside on Stone Street is half of it. Several regulars say it's slipped lately, soggy and short on flavor. The common advice is eat in instead of taking it out, and order it well done.

54 Stone St, New YorkFinancial District, ManhattanGoogle Maps

What Reddit says31

View all
  • replying to u/crazeman: There's a Joe's a few blocks from the memorial. It's more like a slice shop with limited seating though. [Adrienne's Pizza Bar](https://maps.app.goo.gl/7QUNXSHhhBMLwire8) is my pick if you want to sit down and enjoy a nice meal. It's a \~10 min walk but their pizza is excellent if you dine in. I always get the square pie (old fashion I believe) with pepperonis on it.

    I love Adrienne’s, particularly on a nice day when you can sit outside on Stone St.

    H2

  • replying to u/crazeman: There's a Joe's a few blocks from the memorial. It's more like a slice shop with limited seating though. [Adrienne's Pizza Bar](https://maps.app.goo.gl/7QUNXSHhhBMLwire8) is my pick if you want to sit down and enjoy a nice meal. It's a \~10 min walk but their pizza is excellent if you dine in. I always get the square pie (old fashion I believe) with pepperonis on it.

    Came here to recommend Adrienne's, but with the disclaimer that their claim to fame is the grandma / old fashion pies and not quite NY style.

    H2

  • Their pizza used to be really good, but it was pretty soggy and not flavorful the last time I had it.

    H2

  • replying to u/IManageTacoBell: Anyone ever been to Adrienne’s in broad channel?

    Yes. It’s a bit out of the way but if you are nearby, worth trying.

    H2

  • replying to u/HopeForYouYet: Oooof I love Adrienne’s in fidi

    we went a couple weeks ago and it was disappointing. The pizza was soggy and kind of flavorless ☹️

    H2

  • replying to u/26point2miles: Want a cozy Italian place with great food? Il Brigante in the Seaport. Want more of a fun vibe? Mezcali. Higher end and modern? Manahatta (incredible views from up high), The Fulton (on the water, Brooklyn Bridge views), Crown Shy. Classic steakhouse? DelMonico's. Other options: Harry's Italian, Adrienne's Pizza Bar, Mad Dog (Mexican), Felice, Keste.

    Adrienne’s a contender for best pizza in the city.

    H2