Andrea's Pizza

All 42 rated mentions, most helpful first

postAndrea's Pizza. (East Village. 50 2nd Ave)42 pts
“Cheese slice was outstanding. He offered me a fresh slice from a new pie out of the oven. Honestly, no notes.”
H3
postMy favorite spots after a week in NYC233 pts
“I found out about this place through Reddit and wanted to try them out and they did not disappoint! I loved their plain and margherita slices, their ingredients were extremely fresh and high quality.”
H2
postShort pizza tour: Jonny’s, Andrea’s, Lucia (SoHo)41 pts
“Good slice. A little saltier than Jonny’s, which I enjoyed. A better sauce:cheese ratio for me, too. Would def go again. 3.5/5”
H2
in:Fermento Pizza... the best slice no one is talking about?16 pts
“I've tried most of their slices since they've opened, and all have been excellent”
H2
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?11 pts
“Absolute badass slice shop.”
H2
in:Need a reco for your favorite Pizza in SoHo that isn’t Rubirosa!6 pts
replying to u/FEQ648: Arturo's for classic NY style or Song' E Napule for neapolitan style
“my favorite new slice in the vicinity is Andreas on Second”
H2
in:Critique my Google Map for food. It's my first NYC trip and I want to narrow down my options4 pts
“Andrea's is also a relative newcomer in the EV that's making good slices. Very underhyped.”
H2
in:Andrea's Pizza. (East Village. 50 2nd Ave)2 pts
“Tried it today because of your post and it was great!”
H2
in:Andrea's Pizza. (East Village. 50 2nd Ave)2 pts
“The plain cheese slice was utterly delicious, I inhaled it.”
H2
in:First time in NYC. Are we missing something on our 7 day trip?2 pts
replying to u/Resident_Ordinary_39: L’Industrie will probably be crowded. If so, go get a plain slice at mamas too or slice haus. same quality if not better at both. Cellos on st marks is just as good. New Park Pizza in corona is king
“also andrea’s pizza is good as fuck”
H2
in:Our Weekend Visit!1 pts
replying to u/mynewredditaccount_1: we loved it! typically we stop at l’industrie, but the line was wild, and this was on our “try sometime” list! did not disappoint & super friendly staff!
“that and Andrea's were my Manhattan go-to slice shops this trip!”
H2
in:Best Pizza for NYC Day Trip?1 pts
“I'd recommend Andrea's, Pizza Loves Sauce, and Jonny's like others have mentioned.”
H2
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?1 pts
replying to u/Toeknee_F: Andrea’s opened not too long ago on 2nd near the EV. Owner came from Scarr’s and L’Industrie. Absolute badass slice shop.
“Definitely a solid slice, though the dough is holding it back IMO”
H2
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?1 pts
“Give Andrea's a shot, their margherita slice is very underrated!”
H2
in:My favorite spots after a week in NYC14 pts
“they deserve all the love.”
H1
in:What pizza place to swap to for a pizza crawl day in July?10 pts
“Some other good options if they fit with your itinerary: Slicehaus, Fermento, Brooklyn DOP, Andrea's, Norm's.”
H1
in:Recommendations for the best NY Style Pizza in under an hour9 pts
“East Village/LES: Cello’s, village square, pop’s, east village pizza, andreas, Jonny’s, scarrs, unregular”
H1
in:Fermento Pizza... the best slice no one is talking about?7 pts
replying to u/illuminatipastiche: I feel this way about Andrea's on Second Ave. I've tried most of their slices since they've opened, and all have been excellent
“Andrea's is fantastic”
H1
in:Is Scarr's still good? What pizza is the best in the LES?5 pts
replying to u/Used_Concert7413: Jonny's
“Andrea's on 2nd Ave is also great”
H1
in:Andrea's Pizza. (East Village. 50 2nd Ave)4 pts
“Pizza is bangin'. Been back a lot since they opened. Def a great addition to The East Village”
H1
in:Places You Think Are Over-hyped & Where You Would Recommend Going Instead4 pts
“For pizza, popular Manhattan spots like L'Industrie, Bleecker Street, Scarr's, and Lucia of SoHo are overrated and for alternatives, I'd rather go to Andrea's or Pizza Loves Sauce.”
H1
in:Go to repeat restaurant3 pts
replying to u/Snoo-18544: For me I repeat spots in my neighborhood. If it's something I go out of my way for a splurge meal , then I don't want to repeat. My repeats are the numerous places in Les and EV you can spend 35$ for a pretty good dinner or 20ish for a luxury ch. Looking at you BBF, Little Myanmar, Raku, Obiburo house of tsukemen, ramen ishida, izakaya juraku, toriya, cafe mogorador, yuca, three times for your BOGO Xiao long BAO you always have on Uber eats. All those places in china town in walking distance. Oh and trappazino. Also scarrs, Johnny's, 7TH STREET, Saigon social and Casa 13urger oh can't forget mughlai. Also halal cart on delancey/Essex the one that's not across from McDonald's. Popeyes and McDonald's once and a while.
“I see no pizza shop on your list so I would suggest you try out Andrea’s”
H1
in:My favorite spots after a week in NYC3 pts
replying to u/aspiring-green-thumb: I am SUPER impressed with this post!!!!! As an ex Fordham alumni, I love that I see Arthur Ave spots on here!! If you get to go back, I’d highly suggest PUGSLEYS (chicken roll and plain slice with their spicy chili oil - you have to ask at the counter for this) and fresh filled cannolis + rainbow cookies at Madonia Bakery. Since I’m based in EV, I’m stoked to see The Pastry Box and Andrea’s Pizza here as well, they deserve all the love. My husband loves chocolate chip cookies and you did right with Wegmans and The Pastry Box. Well done!!!!!!
“And yeah, Pastry Box, Andrea's and Wegmans were all killer spots and will definitely be staples in my rotation for future visits!”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?3 pts
replying to u/Toeknee_F: Andrea’s opened not too long ago on 2nd near the EV. Owner came from Scarr’s and L’Industrie. Absolute badass slice shop.
“love this place!!”
H1
in:Recent eats - 6 slices and a hot dog: Paulie Gee's (EV), Cello's, Mazzola, Artistic, Koronet, Union Street, Cynthia3 pts
“solid”
H1
in:Recent eats - 6 slices and a hot dog: Paulie Gee's (EV), Cello's, Mazzola, Artistic, Koronet, Union Street, Cynthia3 pts
replying to u/SchnitzelRaider: EV pizza spots: Cello's: vodka slice is great, the rest are super mid Marinara: very underrated, their grandma slice is amazing Andrea's: solid Pop's: mid East Village Pizza and Stromboli: mid, great drunk slices
“Andrea’s is good”
H1
in:Pizza by the slice in the East Village2 pts
“Andrea’s Pizza is the place to go!”
H1
in:Fermento Pizza... the best slice no one is talking about?2 pts
replying to u/illuminatipastiche: I feel this way about Andrea's on Second Ave. I've tried most of their slices since they've opened, and all have been excellent
“Agree. Andrea’s is slept on. Not to be missed!”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?2 pts
replying to u/Toeknee_F: Andrea’s opened not too long ago on 2nd near the EV. Owner came from Scarr’s and L’Industrie. Absolute badass slice shop.
“Andrea's is really solid”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?2 pts
“Some other ones you didn’t mention: Jonny’s, Lucia, Fermento, Slicehaus, Andrea’s. I don’t know if any of them are heads and shoulders *better* than L’Industrie, but I think on a good day they can equal it.”
H1
in:Andrea's Pizza. (East Village. 50 2nd Ave)1 pts
“Just tried it the other night! Def a good spot”
H1
in:Under the radar pizza in Manhattan?1 pts
“Jonny's on Orchard st., and Andrea's on 2nd ave.”
H1
in:Is Scarr's still good? What pizza is the best in the LES?1 pts
replying to u/Bitterfish: Jonny's is excellent <3 Andrea's on 2nd Ave is also great, and Potenza Centrale on Avenue B. Technically not LES, but only like a block north
“if we were extending it to the east village, I'd include Andrea's. I'm digging it so far.”
H1
in:Pizza by the slice in the East Village1 pts
replying to u/MaxLmaxL15: Andrea’s Pizza is the place to go!
“Great spot. Cellos and Andreas are neck and neck”
H1
in:What pizza place to swap to for a pizza crawl day in July?1 pts
“Andrea’s in East Village”
H1
in:Need a reco for your favorite Pizza in SoHo that isn’t Rubirosa!1 pts
“I like them a little bit more.”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?1 pts
“Andreas pizza and grand st pizza”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?1 pts
“Slicehaus and andrea’s”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?1 pts
“Slicehaus or Andreas”
H1
in:First Time Visitor to eat list in, Food suggestions.0 pts
“Andrea's on 2nd Avenue is another decnt spot.”
H1
in:Reigning pizza slice downtown Manhattan? L’industrie?0 pts
replying to u/illuminatipastiche: No idea why you got downvoted. Andrea's is really solid
“It’s solid but was expecting a little better honestly.”
H1
in:Recent eats - 6 slices and a hot dog: Paulie Gee's (EV), Cello's, Mazzola, Artistic, Koronet, Union Street, Cynthia-2 pts
“Should have gone to Andrea’s too.”
H1