“Cheese slice was outstanding. He offered me a fresh slice from a new pie out of the oven. Honestly, no notes.”
H3
8.3/10
AI-generated summary
Get the slice. People point to the thin crispy bottom, the Grande cheese, and the Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes. The margherita slice gets called underrated. A couple of people think the dough is the weak part.
“Cheese slice was outstanding. He offered me a fresh slice from a new pie out of the oven. Honestly, no notes.”
H3
“I found out about this place through Reddit and wanted to try them out and they did not disappoint! I loved their plain and margherita slices, their ingredients were extremely fresh and high quality.”
H2
“Good slice. A little saltier than Jonny’s, which I enjoyed. A better sauce:cheese ratio for me, too. Would def go again. 3.5/5”
H2
“I've tried most of their slices since they've opened, and all have been excellent”
H2
“Absolute badass slice shop.”
H2
“my favorite new slice in the vicinity is Andreas on Second”
H2
“Andrea's is also a relative newcomer in the EV that's making good slices. Very underhyped.”
H2
“Tried it today because of your post and it was great!”
H2
“The plain cheese slice was utterly delicious, I inhaled it.”
H2
“also andrea’s pizza is good as fuck”
H2
“that and Andrea's were my Manhattan go-to slice shops this trip!”
H2
“I'd recommend Andrea's, Pizza Loves Sauce, and Jonny's like others have mentioned.”
H2