Golden Steer

5.4/10

AI-generated summary

People argue about this one. Fans order the and the and like the old school room and the bartenders. Critics say the beef isn't top quality, that the sauces cover for it, and that NYC already has better steakhouses. Only the porterhouse is dry aged and it runs about $225.

What Reddit says31

View all
  • replying to u/Tofuhousewife: I grew up in Vegas and remember going to golden steer a couple times as a kid. I even remember my stepdad buying a GROUPON for the restaurant lol. It’s always been okay. I don’t understand the new hype around it unless they changed and are genuinely top quality, but ehhh I doubt it lol. Wonder how it’ll do here, there are A LOT of good steakhouses in the city.

    I went a few months and it's definitely not top quality. I don't even think they use prime beef, no dry/wet aging, and they really push their sauces to mask the quality and flavor.

    H3

  • I went on Saturday. It was quite good. Considering they've only been open for one week and I've only visited once I'm hesitant to rank it up there with the elite places, but on my visit they were in that same echelon.

    H3

  • replying to u/FUCK_CAPTCHAS: It's gotten a bit of flak on here but I did have dinner in the bar room at Golden Steer and did steak + martini's and thoroughly enjoyed it. Great ambience and old school feel, really good bartenders and a solid martini, thought the tomahawk was excellent as well.

    I had the worst martinis (everyone’s in a large group consistently wrong garnish, warm and vermouth filled even when sent back and asked dry) I’ve had in the city at a place of this caliber but everything else was really nice. I had the big dry aged porterhouse and it was really nice. Steak Mac and cheese also great.

    H3

  • replying to u/RoeMajesta: the vegas location is legit though

    i agree that it doesnt compete with the top tier steakhouses in NYC, but i thought it was solid. i’d go back just for the prime rib mac and cheese

    H2

  • Great ambience and old school feel, really good bartenders and a solid martini, thought the tomahawk was excellent as well.

    H2