Not Ray's Pizza

All 40 rated mentions, most helpful first

postThe most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC190 pts
“Very Cheesy, solid bread that’s not flat, will get filled up after 1 or maybe 2, really good sauce, good toppings (pepperoni never tastes stale), good staff”
H3
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC3 pts
“The first one looks greasy and too cheesy imo”
H2
in:Lindustrie is flavorful but overhyped3 pts
“Not rays pizza on Fulton is prob one of the more underrated spots and it’s not paper thin.”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“The correct order at Not Ray’s is the white ricotta slice”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“they make a great slice”
H2
in:L’Industrie was … good?2 pts
“Not Rays pizza was also really good”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
“Not Ray’s is such a solid slice. The double meat slice is my go-to. 2 slices in one, and it’s actually good and not just a gimmick. I didn’t grow up with it, but even without nostalgia, I can say that it’s one of my favs.”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
“Rays is great if you’re ordering a whole pie they aren’t the best slices”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC0 pts
replying to u/Eat_Ya_Food_Son: Born and raised here too . And joes isn’t bad. But it got hyped up by a lot of ppl in the city and I’ve had it several times and those it was very mid for the hype.
“The slice in pic 1 is perfect, the stuff of dreams”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC0 pts
“This was a stock photo. Not rays def not burnt. Dough is also buttered. Never got a burnt slice”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC0 pts
“not rays pizza is my childhood favorite and is still a great slice of pizza.”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC0 pts
replying to u/BrokenTigress: Omgosh not rays pizza is my childhood favorite and is still a great slice of pizza.
“Underrated. Gets little love in the city, and yet is one of the best slices. The butter crust…cmon…one of the best in the city”
H2
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC13 pts
“These guys are great.”
H1
in:Best slice of pizza in prospect heights/ft greene/clinton hill?12 pts
“Luigis / 3 Luigis , Il Porto , Brooklyn Homeslice , Not Rays were my go-tos when I lived in the area.”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC6 pts
replying to u/Eat_Ya_Food_Son: I grew up with not rays as a kid. And I thought maybe I was too biased. So when I grew up I would go to other spots. And honestly, not rays remained up there with the others.
“Not Ray's is my fave too.”
H1
in:Jaded pizza snobs: what slices still give you that "damn, life is good" sigh of bliss?5 pts
“I love Not Ray's Pizza in Fort Greene!”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC5 pts
“It's a fine slice. It's not that good.”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC3 pts
replying to u/Segundo-Sol: Damn, didn’t expect to see Not Rays Pizza here. These guys are great. The Chinese spot a few steps away is also pretty decent.
“And honestly, not rays remained up there with the others.”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“I love both not rays and joes haha”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“I love not rays”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“not rays is pretty mid.”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“Had it once and will never return”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“I love Not Rays and I’m lucky enough to live by them! I will only get their pizza if I have a choice”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC2 pts
“I grew up by Not Ray's and it's cool to see them get recognized, I definitely second your opinion.”
H1
in:Stuffed slices?2 pts
“Not my thing tho”
H1
in:Best slice of pizza in prospect heights/ft greene/clinton hill?2 pts
“Not Ray's is subpar.”
H1
in:Jaded pizza snobs: what slices still give you that "damn, life is good" sigh of bliss?1 pts
replying to u/srawr42: I love Not Ray's Pizza in Fort Greene!
“I live right by it and honestly find it soo mid”
H1
in:Disappointed by Roberta’s1 pts
“Go to “Not Rays” in Ft. Greene off Fulton St”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
replying to u/Eat_Ya_Food_Son: Joes is ok. Just woefully overrated. If I’m drunk and it’s on my way, I’ll get two slices. But I always feel like it wasn’t worth when I do
“Not rays is dece.”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
replying to u/Subject_Space_2187: I'm sorry but there is no world in which Not Ray's pizza is the most underrated pizza in New York. It's a fine slice. It's not that good. Joe's on most days (I understand quality fluctuates at Joe's, especially when they're busy) blows Not Ray's into smithereens
“Not rays any day over joes.”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
replying to u/DriftingTony: The pizza in that first pic looks horrendous. I would still eat it if it was the only thing available to me though lol
“Picture doesn’t do it justice. Go try it!!!”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
“no complaints it's just unremarkable”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
replying to u/Zazz2403: That's the worst looking joes slice I've ever seen, what location is that?
“Go to not rays in bk and try it out. Trust me”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
“But I tried so many and end up still saying not rays is better than so many of these hyped up spots”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
replying to u/rhubarbjammy: I love Not Rays and I’m lucky enough to live by them! I will only get their pizza if I have a choice
“I tried other spots after I moved from that area and thought I would get better and I really haven’t”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC1 pts
“Try not rays in bk.”
H1
in:Lindustrie is flavorful but overhyped1 pts
replying to u/Eat_Ya_Food_Son: No. I’ve eaten nyc pizza for almost 30 years. Born and raised here. Paper thin isn’t necessarily nyc pizza. Not rays pizza on Fulton is prob one of the more underrated spots and it’s not paper thin. Adrienne’s, which does Sicilian slices, isn’t paper thin. Many places in nyc, even with thin slices, aren’t paper thin. That’s not a nyc thing.
“Sorry but not rays is mid at best”
H1
in:L’Industrie was … good?1 pts
“I prefer Not Ray's in Ft. Greene”
H1
in:Restaurant Recommendations for a couple from California1 pts
“My preference for this is Not Ray's in Brooklyn.”
H1
in:The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC-1 pts
replying to u/ComprehensiveYak6558: I’ve lived in fort Greene for many, many years — not rays is pretty mid. Love the guys there tho
“Nah son (or ma’am) you bugging lol”
H1