“Very Cheesy, solid bread that’s not flat, will get filled up after 1 or maybe 2, really good sauce, good toppings (pepperoni never tastes stale), good staff”
H3
6.0/10
AI-generated summary
People argue about this one. Fans say it's a thick, cheesy slice with a buttered crust, and they order the white ricotta slice or the double meat. Plenty of neighbors call it mid or unremarkable. Whole pies get better reviews than single slices.
“Very Cheesy, solid bread that’s not flat, will get filled up after 1 or maybe 2, really good sauce, good toppings (pepperoni never tastes stale), good staff”
H3
“The first one looks greasy and too cheesy imo”
H2
“Not rays pizza on Fulton is prob one of the more underrated spots and it’s not paper thin.”
H2
“The correct order at Not Ray’s is the white ricotta slice”
H2
“they make a great slice”
H2
“Not Rays pizza was also really good”
H2
“Not Ray’s is such a solid slice. The double meat slice is my go-to. 2 slices in one, and it’s actually good and not just a gimmick. I didn’t grow up with it, but even without nostalgia, I can say that it’s one of my favs.”
H2
“Rays is great if you’re ordering a whole pie they aren’t the best slices”
H2
“The slice in pic 1 is perfect, the stuff of dreams”
H2
“This was a stock photo. Not rays def not burnt. Dough is also buttered. Never got a burnt slice”
H2
“not rays pizza is my childhood favorite and is still a great slice of pizza.”
H2
“Underrated. Gets little love in the city, and yet is one of the best slices. The butter crust…cmon…one of the best in the city”
H2