“But Patsys is really, really good. I almost always get the chicken parm, it’s amazing. When they have the lasagna it’s great too. Everything anyone has got from their they have loved.”
H2
All 48 rated mentions, most helpful first
“But Patsys is really, really good. I almost always get the chicken parm, it’s amazing. When they have the lasagna it’s great too. Everything anyone has got from their they have loved.”
H2
“the food is good and I like the vibe.”
H2
“Great dish, huge portion, too!”
H2
“I love it there. We live in the neighborhood and have dinner there once a month or so. Best chicken scarpariello I’ve ever had, and that includes Italy.”
H2
“Patsy’s in midtown Manhattan. It’s very old school, classic interior, red sauce menu. Still owned by the family that started it.”
H2
“For old school, maybe Patsy’s, a bit farther west. It’s Italian and they will make anything you want, even if not on the menu.”
H2
“Patsys is good fun - old school red sauce Italian and it’s less touristy than the other midtown Italian spots.”
H2
“We're a huge fan of Patsy's. The Chicken Parm is ungodly. So much flavor. Lasagna is pretty much the same way. Desserts are incredible too, iirc we liked the carrot cake the best.”
H2
“Soup of the day at Patsy 's on 56th, not a full dinner meal but good for lunch”
H2
“on 56th (between Broadway and 8th) is an old-school midtown red sauce Italian place.”
H1
“I have eaten in all of them. All Are excellent”
H1
“Patsy’s in midtown.”
H1
“Patsy’s on 56th St is great Italian”
H1
“Patsys on 56 street”
H1
“Patsy’s for today’s patsies.”
H1
“Patsys on 56”
H1
“Seconded. Like walking into a Time Machine”
H1
“Patsy’s on 56th between 8th and Broadway is great Italian.”
H1
“Patsy’s on west 56th.”
H1
“Patsy’s Italian Restaurant on W 56th St is your place.”
H1
“Gene’s on W 11th, Patsys on W 56th, Emilio Ballato on E. Houston but it’s first come first serve”
H1
“Arturo’s, Monte’s, John’s of 12th, patsys”
H1
“John's or Patsy's are the only two answers.”
H1
“Do not go to Carmine's or Patsy's... both are tourist traps with bad service and average food.”
H1
“You'd do better if you go to Patsy's on West 56th Street”
H1
“Reliably good southern Italian-American.”
H1
“If you want pricier, I recommend Patsy’s (the restaurant not the pizzeria)”
H1
“Patsy’s on 56th. Classic NYC.”
H1
“Tourist trap”
H1
“very solid and historic red sauce joint”
H1
“If you want old school Italian, Patsy’s in midtown west or Paul and Jimmys in Gramercy, Genes in GV.”
H1
“Patsy’s if you want a classic red sauce place.”
H1
“Patsy’s on West 56th.”
H1
“Patsy's Pizzeria on W 56thth/Broadway”
H1
“i would probably pick PATSYs….quaint, classic Italian”
H1
“Carmine's or Patsy's”
H1
“Patsy's on 56th St”
H1
“Was there a few months ago. Food was not good. Do not go there.”
H1
“Patsy’s would be my first choice, though.”
H1
“How about Patsy's on West 56th St.”
H1
“accessible, beloved, legit old school & mobster, although i personally didn't love it.”
H1
“Very old school and great food.”
H1
“Patsy’s (56th St/8th ave area) an old classic”
H1
“Patsy’s for sure.”
H1
“I can say I ate there once and didn’t like it one bit. Overrated and expensive.”
H1
“please do not go to Patsys over Pietros”
H1
“I went there once when I first moved here and have never gone again. I eat Italian all the time one of my favorite cuisines. I’m trying to tell you something about a restaurant that I live across the street from and wouldn’t eat at if it was a hail storm outside and I wanted Italian.”
H1
“while it was a bucket list experience, honestly the food is no better than Patsy’s on 56th Street.”
H1