Gelateria Gentile

All 50 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC3 pts
replying to u/NoMastodon8294: 100% gelateria gentile
“weirdly oversugared at times. emphasizes weird flavors over raspberry, strawbeerry, frutti di bosco... never seems to draw a crowd, and kids tried it twice and didn't like it.”
H3
in:Last five months in NYC bucket list?? 158 pts
“Gelato at Gentile - the fior di latte and fondente for simple excellence.”
H2
in:Top Pistachio Gelato spots?13 pts
“Gelateria Gentile has the best pistachio I’ve ever had in my life 🍨”
H2
in:Best pistachio sweets or dessert in the city11 pts
“Pistachio gelato at Gentile, not too sweet and perfection for me.”
H2
in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC7 pts
replying to u/NoMastodon8294: 100% gelateria gentile
“As close to Italy as I’ve ever had, hands down. Brought some family from Italy there and they agreed.”
H2
in:Best places to eat after L’industrie pizza? (Williamsburg)5 pts
“Gelato at Gentile, all of their flavors tend to excellent.”
H2
in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC4 pts
replying to u/NoMastodon8294: 100% gelateria gentile
“Fior de latte is a transcendent flavor there. Best gelato I’ve had in America.”
H2
in:Mint chip aficionados, (I know, I know), what are your favorite places for mint chip that have really crunchy and well-tempered chips?3 pts
“gentile stracciatella is my favorite gelato/ice cream in nyc”
H2
in:Grapefruit Gelato?3 pts
“Just had grapefruit sorbetto at Gelateria Gentile near union square. Absolutely delicious!”
H2
in:Williamsburg spots2 pts
“Gelateria gentile for gelato”
H2
in:What’s your favorite dessert place and order in NYC?2 pts
“For gelato: gentile”
H2
in:Caffe Panna - Overrated?2 pts
“I used to love going to Gelateria Gentile, but I’ve also found that after their rapid expansion over the last couple of years, their flavors are also sweeter.”
H2
in:Recommendations and Opinions Needed!1 pts
“Gelateria Gentile which is the closest I’ve had to gelato in Italy.”
H2
in:Cheesecake ice cream or gelato1 pts
“Gelato go to Gentile”
H2
in:Best pistachio sweets or dessert in the city1 pts
replying to u/ChivalrousWombat: Pistachio gelato at Gentile, not too sweet and perfection for me. They rotate flavors daily so try giving them a call first. A lot of people love the pistachio croissant at Radio Bakery in Greenpoint. I personally didn’t, I found it to have a strange flavor and slightly too sweet for me.
“Yes, the chocolate and fior di latte at Gentile are also excellent.”
H2
in:Best pistachio sweets or dessert in the city1 pts
“I like the pistachio gelato at Gentile.”
H2
in:What are your favorite restaurants in Williamsburg?1 pts
“Gelateria Gentile for gelato”
H2
in:Upcoming NYC Trip with bf's brother & wife - Need Ideas 1 pts
“gelateria gentile for gelato”
H2
in:If you had to spend one full day eating your way through NYC, what would your breakfast, lunch, afternoon coffee/snack, and dinner be?1 pts
“Dessert - Gelateria Gentile, vegan dark chocolate & espresso coffee”
H2
in:Ny in two weeks. Finalizing my restaurant list1 pts
“Gelateria gentile for gelato”
H2
in:Cherry desserts/drinks?1 pts
“Spagnoli Gelato (sour cherry & cream) from Gelateria Gentile is phenomenal!!”
H2
in:Title: 1.5 days left in NYC – what foods should we not miss?0 pts
“rivareno and gentile for traditional gelato”
H2
in:Best authentic gelato for the summer?44 pts
“gelateria gentile (originally from bari, italy) and figo are my favs.”
H1
in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC40 pts
“100% gelateria gentile”
H1
in:VC and private equity owned spots32 pts
replying to u/VeryPuffin: I’ll say, nobody has a bigger and better vegan/non dairy options than VLW. If there is, that aren’t just sorbets at gelato spots, I’m all ears!
“Try Gelateria Gentile.”
H1
in:Best authentic gelato for the summer?31 pts
“Gelateria Gentile - multiple locations”
H1
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?11 pts
“Other favorites: Malai, Morgenstern's, Gentile, Kettl”
H1
in:Best authentic gelato for the summer?11 pts
“The Flavor and richness-wise I’d say Gentile and Anita are the best I’ve tried in nyc so far.”
H1
in:Anita gelato9 pts
“Gelateria gentile is great”
H1
in:Pistachio Ice Cream for blind tasting - requesting recs!8 pts
“i really like pamina & gentile too”
H1
in:What I ate in NYC for 2 days and a half6 pts
“Between Figo and Gentile I will said gentile by far”
H1
in:Best authentic gelato for the summer?5 pts
“The temperature is right and texture is good.”
H1
in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC4 pts
replying to u/NoMastodon8294: 100% gelateria gentile
“Seconded”
H1
in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC4 pts
replying to u/NoMastodon8294: 100% gelateria gentile
“Correct”
H1
in:your top 5 NYC restaurants3 pts
“Gelateria Gentile”
H1
in:Summer - Ice cream/ gelato/ soft serve3 pts
“gentile - they have a few locations downtown Manhattan and one in Williamsburg”
H1
in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC3 pts
replying to u/winkingchef: Fior de latte is a transcendent flavor there. Best gelato I’ve had in America.
“It’s a revelation!”
H1
in:What's your favorite place in NYC to get ice cream in?2 pts
“Gelateria Gentile”
H1
in:Anita gelato2 pts
replying to u/PTRBoyz: Gelateria gentile is great but idk the price off my head
“I loved Anita until I found gentile”
H1
in:looking for quality gelato that is local to NYC2 pts
“Pamina Dolci e Gelato (recent edition to the West Village) or Any of the Gelateria Gentile locations.”
H1
in:Grapefruit Gelato?2 pts
“Gentile on the UWS usually has a good selection of flavors.”
H1
in:Looking for a dinner and dessert tour2 pts
“You can grab dessert at Salt & Straw or Gelateria Gentile and stroll on Hudson St.”
H1
in:Best authentic gelato for the summer?2 pts
“Seconding gentile & l’albero too”
H1
in:What's your most controvertial nyc food scene opinion?1 pts
replying to u/ss4444gogeta: They just opened one near Times Square and it's both larger and less crowded. Honestly I think it's the best gelato I've had in the city, any better recs?
“Gelateria Gentile”
H1
in:Anita gelato1 pts
replying to u/PTRBoyz: Gelateria gentile is great but idk the price off my head
“imo best in the city”
H1
in:Pistachio Ice Cream for blind tasting - requesting recs!1 pts
“gelataria gentile”
H1
in:Searching for! Milk flavored ice cream (Japanese style), rice pudding ice cream, and salted Sakura leaves1 pts
“Gelateria Gentile has one that's great but of course not Japanese style.”
H1
in:itinerary review for part 3 of <72 hours in NYC1 pts
replying to u/AlfalfaTimmy: I didn’t realize it’s in a mall lol. But yes, it’s the mall one! My understanding is that there’s only one location of Mah Ze Dahr now. For Martha’s, the decision is driven primarily based on how close it is to Sunday in Brooklyn. Figured we’d try it due to convenience.
“places that I like more in that general area would be Gelateria Gentile”
H1
in:Looking for good sit down dessert places that are open late1 pts
“Gelateria Gentile in Nolita and Wburg has the best most amazing decadent delicious heaven touching glad to be alive desserts in the city.”
H1
in:Tasty gelato from newcomer to NYC, Bertoni (South Williamsburg)1 pts
“Yes — Gentile”
H1