postLooking for Napolitano-style pizza on UES similar to Motorino/Song e Napule on UWS (but on UES).7 pts
“We tried San Mateo and it was good, close, but not quite. The crust was too dry and not chewy enough, the mushrooms were canned.”
H3
All 40 rated mentions, most helpful first
“We tried San Mateo and it was good, close, but not quite. The crust was too dry and not chewy enough, the mushrooms were canned.”
H3
“San Matteo in the UES has one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. It’s on a “pizza bun” (oven-cooked dough I believe) and makes use of a very good cut of meat, and intentional toppings.”
H3
“San Matteo on 81st has killer Pat LaFreda dry aged steaks and their crust rivals the best of them.”
H2
“San Matteo is a bit of a walk but excellent pizza and wine.”
H2
“San Matteo on 81 has a v good burger”
H2
“Yeah great service when I went there on a Saturday (lunch time).”
H2
“Best Pizza - San Matteo or Prince Street”
H2
“San Matteo is great for pizza, but not much else.”
H2
“San Matteo on 2nd ave and 88 or 89. Everyone loves good pizza.”
H2
“San Matteo for the pizza and apps”
H2
“San Matteo had a unique but good burger last I was there.”
H2
“San Matteo for Neapolitan pizza.”
H2
“Great quantity & quality. Loaded charcuterie board, bruschetta, mini sliders & fries and more.”
H2
“San Matteo on the UES has great neapolitan”
H2
“Vietnaam, San Matteo, The Gatsby Sandwich from Kaia, Chicken Insider would all be my go-tos.”
H1
“San Matteo on UES”
H1
“San Matteo”
H1
“San matteo”
H1
“San Mateo”
H1
“A few of my top picks: Sushi W, San Matteo (pizza), AOC East (French), Pho Shop, Chicken Insider (KFC), Anita Gelato, and Van Leeuwen (ice cream).”
H1
“San Matteo on the UES”
H1
“San matteo”
H1
“San Matteo’s on 91st and 2nd”
H1
“Other options I haven’t seen on this thread are Osteria Morini or San Matteo”
H1
“Never had a bad meal there I love it!”
H1
“Solid. Quite the hustle when I was there, but definitely solid”
H1
“San Mateo is quality Italian casual with Napolitan pizza oven and $22-28 entrees.”
H1
“san matteo is probably still one of the closest matches.”
H1
“Cacio e pepe, Ribalta, Fiaschetteria Pistoia, Malatesta, Song A Napule, and San Matteo are solid italian places :)”
H1
“San Matteo in the Upper East Side and Pizza Secret in Park Slope are the city’s two best locations for pizza napoletana in my opinion”
H1
“They're all so good, and the specials they do with appetizers and pizzas are fantastic too.”
H1
“San Mateo”
H1
“San Matteo UES”
H1
“San Matteo on the upper east side!”
H1
“San Mateo ( two location on 2nd 81/89th) - the local hype is real”
H1
“I’d start at Yefsi ( Greek) on York/78th, or San Mateo ( napolitan pizza & Italian mom & pop) owned at either locations.”
H1
“We tried San Mateo and it was good, close, but not quite.”
H1
“Donna Margherita and San matteo”
H1
“San Matteo”
H1
“I’ve been in Normandie Court, right where you are, for 10 years and these are all my best recos.”
H0