All 51 rated mentions, most helpful first
“For anyone who has not tried it, Lucky Charlie's is unbelievable. I believe they have the oldest coal oven in the western hemisphere and the pizza tastes like it (in a good way). Incredible char, maybe the best sauce I've ever had on a pizza - its just perfectly tangy but with not too much sweetness.”
H3
“Was disappointed. My wife and I went there this past Saturday, the pie was definitely the crispiest we've ever had but a DiGiornos frozen pie has more flavor than lucky charlie's.”
H3
“Had it yesterday, great pie but L'Industrie still beats it with overall flavor and Lucali has an edge on mastery of that thin crust. The red sauce is pretty on point though, white sauce was subpar.”
H3
“I think i prefer dry mozzarella over fresh mozzarella but still an enjoyable pizza. Not sure I’d wait an hour or go to bushwick again though but glad I tried it.”
H2
“Lucky Charlie has got the best pie in the city.”
H2
“that place is awesome and the vibe is great as well.”
H2
“its really good. not the best pie though.”
H2
“The best pizza in all of NYC and it’s *still* not a 10/10. Damn, son.”
H2
“Then have one of their most excellent Pizzas!”
H2
“It’s solid pizza though.”
H2
“Lucky Charlie is legit the only 10/10 pizza I have had in NY.”
H2
“Lucky Charlie’s is the best pizza rn”
H2
“Sometimes they overcook it and it's more of a hot cracker than a pizza, but when they get it right, it's up there for sure.”
H2
“I wanted to like it but it was soggy. Did like coal fired tho”
H2
“Overrated”
H2
“Lucky Charlie for the best pizzas, serves till 2am”
H2
“The tiramisu at i cavallini or the tiramisu at Lucky Charlie!”
H2
“Thought the white was better than their regular!”
H2
“caesar salad there is bomb”
H2
“Lucky Charlie does this overcooks.the dough til it's a cracker. Like if I want to eat a slice later and that crust is a rock you fail as a pizza maker in my opinion.”
H2
“it’s the best going anytime from 10pm-3am and be able to get amazing pizza and drinks without waiting for a table or res.”
H2
“How about some WORTH IT spots? Johns of Bleeker, Lucky Charlie, Mamas Too, Lindustrie”
H2
“Chrissy’s and Lucky Charlie both have awesome red pies! Source: I only eat cheese-less pizza.”
H2
“Yes. Their Tiramisu is in the conversation as well.”
H2
“Lucky Charlie's is great, but the clientele sucks *so* fucking hard now that it's in "Eater-pilled" territory.”
H1
“If you’re looking for coal oven and delicious I would say Lucky Charlie in Bushwick is your best bet.”
H1
“I do like lucky Charlie, it’s a few blocks away”
H1
“lucky charlie's”
H1
“Really inconsistent”
H1
“Highly suggest hustling over there before it completely blows up”
H1
“Pizza is outstanding and better than what I had in New Haven. Has other great food and drinks are delicious as well.”
H1
“You’d be better off making the trek to brooklyn for Lucky Charlie”
H1
“I’d just go to Lucky Charlie .”
H1
“went on NYE and the pie was genuinely awful. maybe i just went on the wrong day but i won't be going back”
H1
“lucky Charlie's is one of my favorites”
H1
“F&F, Luigi's, Lucali, Lucky Charlie in Brooklyn.”
H1
“Or go to Lucky Charlie in Bushwick for a night trip and something really uniquely NYC.”
H1
“Top 5 in that area . Not top 50 in NYC”
H1
“some of the most mouthwatering shrimp I’ve ever had.”
H1
“Lucky Charlie”
H1
“Seconding Lucky Charlie's”
H1
“Lucky Charlie’s is the closest.”
H1
“That or Lucky Charlie’s”
H1
“Check out lucky Charlie’s”
H1
“Omg the best pizza and the best vibe. The staff are so fun and funny. Go to Lucky Charlie !!!”
H1
“To me it is definitely top 5.”
H1
“For Bushwick it’s definitely top 5. For all of nyc no shot.”
H1
“Incorrect”
H1
“definitely has a place in top 10 <3”
H1
“I did love this place and live nearby.”
H1