Pylos

All 57 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:STOLEN FROM /r/FoodLA (again): What's Your Top NYC Restaurant Pick? Upvote if Untried, Downvote if Dined There. Let's Unearth Hidden Eateries!13 pts
“great food, service and beautiful space.”
H2
in:Lamb Chops?5 pts
“Great Greek and awesome lamb chops.”
H2
in:Looking for charming Italian, Greek, or American food with unique decor for anniversary dinner3 pts
“Pylos is underrated”
H2
in:Best Lamb Dishes / Lamb Shank?2 pts
“The lamb shank basted in a honey sauce from Pylos in East Village is very good”
H2
in:Greek restaurant with a fun/memorable atmosphere with great food in manhattan?2 pts
“Slightly better food with an interesting atmosphere- Pylos”
H2
in:Cheese-heavy restaurants1 pts
replying to u/goldenapple212: Any greek restaurants that have saganaki (e.g. Pylos), any Mexican restaurant with queso fundido (e.g. Casa Azul), any great pizzeria with a quattro formaggi (e.g. Ribalta), deep dish pizza at Emmett's, the truffle honey pizza at Emily, Taureau for fondue, the mozzarella sticks at Big Mozz at Smorgasburg...
“their saganaki “three Greek cheeses melted in a clay pot” is insane”
H2
in:Affordable large group dinner1 pts
“Excellent food, cute place and good service.”
H2
in:What restaurants are in your current top 5?1 pts
replying to u/andthrewaway1: Wow.. Pylos. I'e been walking by it for years and never really thought oh hey I should go there. Thanks for the rec
“gigantes sto fourno (random but incredibly flavorful benas), haloumi or saganaki (i make haloumi at home, so I go for saganaki, but both are great), afrata keftedakia (meatballs), octopus, the lamb main dish, their steak is great and made greek style, love their lamb chops.”
H2
in:NYC reservations / feedback1 pts
“Not bad but they only serve Greek wine which was not that good”
H2
in:What’s your favorite NYC restaurant?1 pts
“Delicious food and great service, it is a gem! The best octopus and Greek salad in the city.”
H2
in:Reddit NYC Foodies: We are in grave need of your help! Planning a tour of melted cheese dishes1 pts
“Saganaki at Pylos 🫕”
H2
in:Pylos @ East Village1 pts
“I love their lamb chops and lemon potatoes on the side. Plus a horiatiki salad”
H2
in:Pylos @ East Village1 pts
“Such a great place! Going this weekend after few months, can’t wait!”
H2
in:If you could have just one dish, from one restaurant...1 pts
“Pylos greek salad”
H2
in:Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants?26 pts
“I've never had anything other than a fantastic meal anytime I've gone to Pylos.”
H1
in:Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants?17 pts
“Pylos”
H1
in:Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants?14 pts
“Best one I've had otherwise is Pylos”
H1
in:best fried zucchini in the city?8 pts
“Pylos. Oh my god, Pylos.”
H1
in:Best Greek food 7 pts
“Loved Pylos in the city”
H1
in:What are your favorite upscale Greek/Mediterranean Restaurants in Manhattan?7 pts
“Pylos”
H1
in:Creative, unique, delicious, easy to get a table, but affordable. Budget of $200 for 2 people. Is this possible?7 pts
“Pylos is good greek”
H1
in:Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants?6 pts
“Also Pylos”
H1
in:Greek food near or around midtown6 pts
“Pylos.”
H1
in:Food near the angelika on the east side5 pts
“Also recommend Cafe Mogador, Pylos, and Empellon Al Pastor.”
H1
in:Pylos @ East Village5 pts
“Went there last night with brother and it was amazing”
H1
in:What’s your goto restaurant when you don’t want to plan ahead?4 pts
“Pylos”
H1
in:Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants?4 pts
replying to u/Cartadimusica: Pylos
“Agree. Pylos is great.”
H1
in:Where can I get the best grilled lamb chops?3 pts
“Periyali and Pylos.”
H1
in:What restaurants are in your current top 5?3 pts
replying to u/andthrewaway1: Wow.. Pylos. I'e been walking by it for years and never really thought oh hey I should go there. Thanks for the rec
“Yes. It’s excellent!”
H1
in:Date - Mediterranean Food3 pts
“Pylos is cute, in the East Village.”
H1
in:Best Greek food 3 pts
“Nerai. Bahari. Astoria Seafood. Pylos. All excellent for different reasons.”
H1
in:Recommendations for romantic dinner date in NYC? (up to $100 per person)3 pts
“Pylos”
H1
in:What’s one underrated NYC restaurant you always take out-of-towners to (that’s not super touristy)?3 pts
“Pylos”
H1
in:Pylos @ East Village3 pts
“it’s great!!!”
H1
in:Recommendations for NYC Birthday Dinner for boyfriend?2 pts
“Pylos for Greek!”
H1
in:Must-go places in 20242 pts
“Pylos”
H1
in:Gigante Beans2 pts
“but they changed it a bit now it’s watery”
H1
in:East village2 pts
“Pylos for Greek!”
H1
in:Pylos @ East Village2 pts
“Great spot. Pottery hanging from the ceiling, right?”
H1
in:Best upscale seafood restaurants in Manhattan1 pts
“Pylos is Greek and their seafood is amazing.”
H1
in:Eating out in East Village1 pts
“Pylos is fantastic greek”
H1
in:Looking for charming Italian, Greek, or American food with unique decor for anniversary dinner1 pts
“Pylos”
H1
in:Group of 4, Food Recs, Manhattan, Dietary Restrictions1 pts
“pylos”
H1
in:40th birthday weekend meals1 pts
“Frank, Shuka, Pylos, Tolo…all excellent.”
H1
in:Best Greek dishes in NYC?1 pts
“Seconding Pylos!!”
H1
in:What are your favorite upscale Greek/Mediterranean Restaurants in Manhattan?1 pts
“Nerai or Pylos.”
H1
in:Restaurant week menu1 pts
“Pylos is very tasty. Been a numerous amount of times”
H1
in:Restaurant week menu1 pts
“I eat regularly at Pylos 13 years now, it is a great restaurant, that is why I wanted to share! Menu has some of the best classic Greek dishes.”
H1
in:Date night ideas near Ukranian Village / East Village?1 pts
“I love Pylos for Greek”
H1
in:Pylos @ East Village1 pts
“Really great food.”
H1