All 64 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Had both a couple weeks back. Been meaning to go since I live nearby-ish. Was underwhelmed with both tbh. Both solid, but I think I’m finding I don’t prefer the heavier/crispier cook that so many of the new wave places favor. Also tbf, the slices I got from Diamond seemed like they had been sitting out for a while.”
H3
“Anyway, I think Diamond Slice is in my upper tier. Wouldn’t travel from another neighborhood on a regular basis, but my first choice if I’m nearby.”
H3
“I just happened to walk by it today and was so surprised at how good the spicy vodka slice was!”
H2
“Ah yes the well done slice. Perfect”
H2
“Question of preference but I like my slices very light on dairy, would have preferred a slightly higher salt content in the grated cheese though…”
H2
“I find it too dry! Not enough cheese.”
H2
“Better than Chrissy’s, cheaper than Chrissy’s, nicer than Chrissy’s, quicker than Chrissy’s.”
H2
“It’s really good, the prices are right, and the space inside feels nice, relaxed, unpretentious.”
H2
“Place is very underrated”
H2
“caesar salad slice here is insane, it's like a whole side salad on there and it's prob the best caesar slice in town”
H2
“I thought it was top notch. Lot of options and I dug the vibe.”
H2
“Diamond slice does their supreme with house sausage and pepperonis but is probably the best I’ve tried so far”
H2
“all definitely worth the trip”
H2
“I really like the caesar slice, too. Though it's definitely better when it's fresh because they don't reheat it.”
H2
“The marinara slice at Diamond Slice in Greenpoint is incredible.”
H2
“Got 2 slices while buzzed and they just did not hit. At all”
H2
“This place is slept on because the service, vibe, and food were all great.”
H2
“Yup the topping heavy pizzas are definitely the way to go with the crispy crust they do at Diamond. Their lighter slices I find a little dry.”
H2
“Best slice in GP”
H2
“its great pizza, but even better staff.”
H2
“L’industrie and Diamond and Best are all very crushable slices.”
H2
“Great pizza.”
H2
“good crust, like the fresh parm and basil on top. proper slice”
H2
“Yeah they're great. Try the mushroom slice”
H2
“Lucia of ave x, Jonnys and diamond slice for actual great slices”
H2
“I haven’t seen a slice Iike this in…it’s been a while.”
H2
“I far prefer their pizza to Diamond Slice and Chrissy's (gasp, sacrilege I know).”
H2
“That slice is burnt dude”
H2
“New personal Top 5 contender”
H1
“Excellent slices can be had at Jonny's, Philomena's, Best, Diamond Slice, F&F, Paulie Gee's Slice Shop, SliceHaus, Fermento, or Patsy's in East Harlem.”
H1
“you can pivot to Best Pizza, Fini, Diamond Slice etc for a slice of the same quality.”
H1
“To me, it’s a top 10 slice.”
H1
“stretch, diamond slice, norms, Fini, Leo’s, Lucia F&F…”
H1
“Diamond Slice is better regardless”
H1
“Try if you’re in the neighborhood: Rubirosa, NY pizza suprema, Paulie G’s, Diamond Slice, Scarr’s, Joes, Slicehaus, L&B Spumoni Gardens”
H1
“Diamond slice”
H1
“I’d skip paulie g’s and try diamond slice or Best Pizza.”
H1
“Good looking crust but needs more cheese yearmee”
H1
“im always torn between the two. if im by myself, its Diamond. If im with some friends, its Chrissys then more slices at Diamond. lol”
H1
“Diamond slice”
H1
“Diamond slice”
H1
“There are a bunch of spots in Brooklyn that you should try, r/nycpizzacrawl has hit them up recently. Rome to Brooklyn, Brooklyn DOP, Best Pizza, Patsy’s, Diamond Slice, Paulie Gees, lots of places.”
H1
“I had it few months ago, it’s good!”
H1
“My 10yo is a total pizza snob and was like this isn’t that good- l’indystrie, best and diamond slice are much better…”
H1
“I've been loving diamond slice lately”
H1
“Looks perfect to me.”
H1
“Russ and daughters Scarrs/ Diamond slice/ l Industrie Misi Would be my pick for 3 out of the options provided.”
H1
“Fini and Diamond Slice are my favorite”
H1
“Diamond Slice”
H1
“Diamond slice and motorino”
H1