Eisenberg'sCLOSED

6.5/10

AI-generated summary

Eisenberg's is now S&P Lunch in the Flatiron. People said the was the best in the city, and the corned beef and the got named too. It was a no frills lunch counter and regulars warned the sandwiches were big enough to put you in a coma.

What Reddit says23

View all

in:B&H vs. Russ and Daughters for sit-down latkes?8 pts
“S&P (formerly Eisenbergs) has pretty good latkes.”
H2
in:Recommend me your go to diner, mine’s jumped the shark6 pts
“Eisenbergs is still around. They're no frills and their sandwiches will put you in a coma.”
H2
in:24 Hours in Manhattan Recs4 pts
“I love eisenbergs (now s+p), their pastrami reuben is absolutely the best in the city.”
H2
in:Best BLT in the city?2 pts
“The answer is Eisenberg’s now called S&P in the flatiron. Exceptional BLT rear round.”
H2
in:What’s one food spot in NYC that’s actually gotten better in the last 5 years?2 pts
replying to u/mcdj: Eisenberg’s
“That egg salad with bacon sandwich tho”
H2
in:The thought of Katz’s gives me anxiety…1 pts
“Eisenberg's/S&P Lunch has fantastic corned beef”
H2
in:Great chicken salad sandwich?1 pts
replying to u/donut_butt: For me, the gold standard of chicken salad sandwiches was from Eisenberg's. I don't think I was as floored by S&P's chicken salad, but some of that may have been due to the passage of time. So I'd still recommend S&P and Court Street Grocer for this.
“The chicken itself was really really good, but it’s so big and tall it’s not a very portable lunch.”
H2
in:Casual/counter service lunch in midtown/flatiron1 pts
“Eisenberg’s has great sandwiches”
H2

See all 23 mentions