Il Cantinori

All 68 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:What is your favorite (Italian food) restaurant in the City? (separate by cheap and expensive)16 pts
“Il Cantinori. There’s better Italian food in the City but I love the old school NYC vibe and service here.”
H2
in:High End Italian: Is It Really About the Food?11 pts
“Il Cantinori served me a huge portion of hand made pappardelle with meat sauce for $32. Great main course.”
H2
postIl Cantinori Calf Liver Entree (other beef or pork liver suggestions?)8 pts
“I absolutely loved this dish from Il Cantinori!”
H2
in:Manhattan pasta spots — Rezdora, L'Artusi, or Via Carota6 pts
“Il Cantinori is underrated”
H2
in:Where is this…?3 pts
“That said, their portions are generous and the pappardelle with sausage and peas is worth it.”
H2
in:Il Cantinori Calf Liver Entree (other beef or pork liver suggestions?)2 pts
“Besides Il Cantinori, the only other place I order calves liver.”
H2
in:Leaving NYC in one month, what should I absolutely try? 1 pts
“Calves liver at Il Cantinori.”
H2
in:I realized I've never tried Risotto. What are good options in Lower Manhattan?1 pts
“The risotto at Il Cantinori is very good.”
H2
in:Last Meal Before Moving18 pts
“Aquavit. Il Cantinori. Hawksmoor. The Grill. Au cheval. Some of my favorites.”
H1
in:What’s one underrated NYC restaurant you always take out-of-towners to (that’s not super touristy)?11 pts
“IL Cantinori”
H1
in:Best (somewhat affordable) Italian where a reservation is attainable- for proposal evening11 pts
“IL Cantinori”
H1
in:Italian food for my parents 6 pts
“How about one of the old school places in the Village? Da Andrea, Il Cantinori, Arte, Gene’s…”
H1
in:Best restaurant in Little Italy on Mulberry St6 pts
“Just walk through, then get good Italian someplace else. Like Il Cantinori.”
H1
in:What is your favorite (Italian food) restaurant in the City? (separate by cheap and expensive)5 pts
replying to u/Choth21: Il Cantinori. There’s better Italian food in the City but I love the old school NYC vibe and service here. Also a big fan of Hearth.
“Came here to say Il Cantinori. This description is spot on.”
H1
in:Best Italian in the Village?5 pts
“Bar pitti, il cantinori, 1 fifth, lupa, babbo, il mulino”
H1
in:What restaurants have kept up consistently high quality over the years?3 pts
“Il Cantinori.”
H1
in:Italian Restaurant Recommendations for Date Night3 pts
“Il cantinori”
H1
in:Best Italian in the Village?3 pts
“Il Cantinori is one of my favorites.”
H1
in:What’s one underrated NYC restaurant you always take out-of-towners to (that’s not super touristy)?3 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Italian restaurant for birthday3 pts
“Il cantinori”
H1
in:Dads 60th birthday dinner3 pts
“Scalinatella or il cantinori!”
H1
in:Dinner Date for GF's Birthday - Recommendations??3 pts
“For Italian Il Cantinori is excellent as well.”
H1
in:Villanelle permanently closed - where to go for similar vibe around the WV?2 pts
“It’s old school but Il Cantinori never disappoints.”
H1
in:Which restaurants do you like in the village2 pts
“Il Cantinori.”
H1
in:Best food options around union square?2 pts
“but it is really good.”
H1
in:What are your top 3 restaurants that you dine at the most often because they’re always consistently good, not hard to get into, and the staff recognizes you?2 pts
“Orso. Smith and Wollensky Grill. Il Cantinori.”
H1
in:Must try restaurants near Washington Square Park?2 pts
“il cantinori!!”
H1
in:Tell me where else to go2 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Recommendations for genuinely underrated nice-ish restaurants in Manhattan. Leaning towards authentic Italian but open to others! (No steakhouses, sorry)2 pts
“I think IL Cantinori is very underrated. Beautiful restaurant. Food is very good. Service is great.”
H1
in:Best Italian in the Village?2 pts
“but I love Il Cantinori.”
H1
in:Best veal parm in Manhattan?2 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Recommendations for 3-day trip2 pts
“My favorite Italian in NYC are Hearth and Il Cantinori.”
H1
in:Good restaurants that are easier to get a table at2 pts
“Scalinatella, il cantinori, avra, pastis”
H1
in:CARBONES OR DON ANGIE2 pts
“carbone, il cantinori, forsythia, fiascheterria (excuse my spelling) are other less talked about but solid spots”
H1
in:Graduation Dinner Recs?2 pts
“IL Cantinori!”
H1
in:Yes I am a NYer & no I cannot think of a place for dinner2 pts
“Arthur & Sons, Il Cantinori, Canto, Morandi, Alice, Via13”
H1
in:Fresh pasta without heavy sauce- any reccs much appreciated!2 pts
“Elio's, Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Ideas for my birthday dinner that won't break the bank?1 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Restaurant recommendations for my wife's birthday?1 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Best romantic spot on city for a birthday dinner?1 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Where is this in NYC?1 pts
“Il Cantinori??? Might not be mildly... might be very?”
H1
in:Italian Birthday Dinner Help1 pts
“Il Cantinori or Palma are not on your list but have a similar atmosphere, good for a birthday, and better food IMO.”
H1
in:What are your top 3 restaurants that you dine at the most often because they’re always consistently good, not hard to get into, and the staff recognizes you?1 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Restaurant for visiting parents (alternative to Carbone) 1 pts
“Il Cantinori or Il Buco.”
H1
in:A bookable italian restaurant for my anniversary?1 pts
“Il Gattopardo. Il Cantinori. Gabriel’s.”
H1
in:Dark, Cozy Restaurants1 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:Italian restaurant recommendations?1 pts
“Scalinatella, il cantinori, or campagnola”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?1 pts
“Il Cantinori”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?1 pts
“The answer is either Elios or Il Cantinori.”
H1
in:Upscale place an NYC local would like?1 pts
“Il cantinori”
H1