“Vinyl is my favorite in Manhattan. A bit more creative than most other steakhouses and one of the only places I've been to where they nail the cook on the steak every single time.”
H3
All 70 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Vinyl is my favorite in Manhattan. A bit more creative than most other steakhouses and one of the only places I've been to where they nail the cook on the steak every single time.”
H3
“Vinyl Steakhouse in Flatiron! Dude, so fucking good. The food is unreal and the vibe is so good.”
H3
“FWIW I’ve recently had outstanding service at Lord’s, Corkbuzz, Casa Mono and Vinyl Steakhouse.”
H2
“I think the only Manhattan steakhouse where I've \*never\* had a messed-up cook on the steak. It's always right, every time.”
H2
“Nice bar too”
H2
“My favorite steaks in the city: Vinyl (or their offshoot Vinile), St. Anselm, Noreetuh.”
H2
“I love that place and the owner does a really great job migrating (?) among the patrons. It checks a lot of boxes.”
H2
“They're great, a little more casual / creative, similar to the Anselm vibe.”
H2
“Chambers, Noreetuh, the Bar Room at Aquavit, and Vinyl are all consistently delicious, with great service, and are 1000% on top of accommodating my gluten-free situation.”
H2
“Great Steakhouse, awesome bar, and a chill atmosphere.”
H2
“Hawksmoor over Vinyl for steak or maybe even Cote.”
H2
“Vinyl is very good, not too stuffy nor too expensive.”
H2
“Second Vinyl. Excellent food and staff”
H2
“great appetizers and sides, knowledgeable servers, very strong wine collection and the steak is definitely pretty good”
H2
“Best Steakhouse with a first date vibe...that's an easy one. Vinyl Steakhouse on W 19th.”
H2
“Vinyl is excellent. Their porterhouse isn't bad at all. Not my favorite, but more than great.”
H2
“Vinyl Steakhouse in Flatiron--the best I've ever had”
H2
“this place is a hidden gem and worth it.”
H2
“Places that I've been to more than once and had good consistent service and food.”
H2
“Venyl's porterhouse is fantastic.”
H2
“It’s not as formal as your typical steakhouse, and it has an amazing vibe.”
H2
“In addition to great steaks, Vinyl is a superb spot if you've got vegetarians in your party. While it's not for me, my friend thoroughly enjoyed the plant-based protein "steak".”
H2
“Think it has a good vibe for "steakhouse" date. Great service too.”
H2
“1 - solid food 2 - great vibes.”
H2
“For my money the steak is better than Keens.”
H2
“Great food, great people, corkage-friendly, lots of options besides steaks.”
H2
“I've also had a nice time at Vinyl Steakhouse the couple times I went, and I thought the steak was good.”
H1
“I had a really good experience at Vinyl.”
H1
“Vinyl Steakhouse”
H1
“Vinyl is so good, and not too far from Penn. I would rather go there than quite a few of the more expensive / more well-known spots.”
H1
“Vinyl all day”
H1
“Very mediocre with 5star reviews. Must be bots”
H1
“Same here. My vote would be Vinyl.”
H1
“I thought Vinyl Steakhouse was excellent”
H1
“Vinyl on W. 35th is excellent.”
H1
“Vinyl steakhouse on w19th, hidden gem in my opinion!”
H1
“Vinyl, Vinile, St. Anselm.”
H1
“Vinyl steakhouse”
H1
“Wolfgangs in tribeca and vinyl steakhouse in flatiron are both very good”
H1
“Vinyl in Flatiron”
H1
“Club A and Vinyl are two great options.”
H1
“Vinyl Steakhouse !”
H1
“My vegan friends say it's very, very good.”
H1
“Vinyl Steakhouse..great music as well”
H1
“In no particular order; Quality Meats, Vinyl, Del Frisco's”
H1
“Always treated well at Vinyl Steakhouse”
H1
“Vinyl s good but i feel is more of a date spot”
H1
“Lately I’ve been favoring new school steakhouse (ex Vinyl steakhouse, Bowery meat co, Hawksmoor)”
H1
“Vinyl on 19th St. is excellent.”
H1
“Chambers, Noreetuh, Vinyl Steakhouse, Keen’s, Wonton Garden, Rolo’s, Maxi’s noodle, LN1380, Mido’s, hill country, Boon Dee Moo Ka Ta, mama fina’s,”
H1