“Schmackery's (great variety and seasonal menu at good price point)”
H2
5.7/10
AI-generated summary
People argue about these cookies. Fans go for the and the other frosted cookies, plus rotating flavors like the sweet corn one. Others call them dry and flavorless, and even regulars admit the doesn't stack up against Levain.
“Schmackery's (great variety and seasonal menu at good price point)”
H2
“the White Island cookie (white chocolate, macadamia nut, coconut) was AWESOME.”
H2
“Do not and I repeat do not sleep on the funfetti cookie at Schmackery’s.”
H2
“a very mid cookie unfortunately ):”
H2
“Schmackary's cookies are pretty good”
H2
“Their cookies are the WORST.”
H2
“Schmackery's Cookies and Cream cookie (closer in flavors)”
H2
“SCHMACKERYS IN MIDTOWN FANTASTIC COOKIES”
H2
“Shmackarys was so mediocre, especially compared to levain”
H2
“Levain or Schmackary's cookies”
H2
“Get cookies at Schmackary’s on W 45th right in the theater district.”
H2
“Take her to Schmackary’s in the theater district for cookies.”
H2