“Steve’s is hands-down the worst key lime pie I’ve had. It’s extremely sugary. The filling skimps on the lime and is mostly filler and condensed milk.”
H3
All 63 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Steve’s is hands-down the worst key lime pie I’ve had. It’s extremely sugary. The filling skimps on the lime and is mostly filler and condensed milk.”
H3
“Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in Red Hook is pretty great. They only make Key Lime pies though.”
H2
“then get key lime Steve's.”
H2
“Steve's, yes - Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is the way. 💯”
H2
“If you don't mind a schlep- Steve's Key Lime Pie in Red Hook.”
H2
“Steve’s Key Lime Pie.”
H2
“Steves definitely but Red Hook is tough to get to.”
H2
“Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in Red Hook”
H2
“Steve’s authentic key lime pie. I love key lime pie”
H2
“Steve’s Key Lime Pie.”
H2
“Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie”
H2
“Steve’s in Red Hook is VERY good.”
H2
“I'm not even into key lime pie much, but that was phenomenal!”
H2
“Also shout-out to Steve's Key Lime Pie”
H2
“Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie in Red Hook”
H2
“key lime pie has a graham cracker crust try Steve’s”
H2
“- Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie”
H2
“So, not 💯 on point, but would probably scratch the itch, Steve’s frozen key lime pie bar on a stick. Red Hook. 😋”
H2
“Steve’s Key Lime pie”
H2
“I couldn't like it :( there wasn't much key lime flavour, and it verged on cloy.”
H2
“You can inject straight key lime into my veins. They use real key limes too. Most are fake”
H2
“I really like Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie!”
H2
“Steves for key lime”
H2
“Holy shit that was good The perfect combination of tart and creamy”
H2
“Steve’s in Red Hook for Key Lime Pie.”
H2
“my vote is for Steve’s key lime pie”
H2
“Steve’s rules. I’d say take an Uber but I’m pretty sure they’d be closed at a time you’d want dessert after dinner. If you have time some other time though, their Swingle is to die for. It’s the pie on a stick, dipped in chocolate. EXACTLY as good as it sounds.”
H2
“Get Steve’s.”
H2
“+ a million for Steve’s key lime”
H2
“Cait's key lime is 10000x better!”
H2
“Steve's for key lime pie!”
H2
“Key Lime Pie (they get it from Steve’s, fucking amazing)”
H2
“chocolate covered key lime pie from Steve’s”
H2
“Tart, fresh, no frills. Worth the trip every time.”
H2
“steve's authentic key lime pie (get the swingle)”
H2
“Then enjoy Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie by the water”
H2
“this is the worst key lime pie i’ve ever had”
H2
“Steve's in Red Hook is good!”
H1
“It’s the best dessert this city has to offer IMO.”
H1
“A classic, but Steve's key lime pie. Go to the source in Red Hook instead of old ass pies in grocery stores.”
H1
“Not in Queens, but Steve's Key Lime Pie is a great excuse to explore Red Hook! I like riding my bike there and sitting in the park with my individual-sized pie.”
H1
“Third. Steve’s and nothing comes close.”
H1
“Hometown BBQ, Brooklyn Crab, Sunny’s, Strong rope, Steve’s key lime pie makes for a perfect day.”
H1
“Steves is runner up.”
H1
“Third! I used to live in South Florida and Steve's is legit”
H1
“Steve's is good, great even but it's far away.”
H1
“Co-sign!”
H1
“Yes I remember trying it and being like…. People come all the way to red hook for this..?”
H1
“- Steve’s Key Lime Pie”
H1
“the key lime pie from steves was a hit at a friendsgiving in nj and I picked it up the day before with no issue”
H1