“shelskys for a “member of the tribe” on a bialy”
H2
All 69 rated mentions, most helpful first
“shelskys for a “member of the tribe” on a bialy”
H2
“Shelsky's on Atlantic Ave. is top tier. Not cheap, but very high quality.”
H2
“Shelsky's in Brooklyn has a great pretzel bagel”
H2
“Shelsky’s salmon on a bialy is always worth the splurge.”
H2
“Shelskys does a good whitefish salad”
H2
“Shelskys for a bialy and lox (specifically Member of the Tribe)”
H2
“am I crazy to think shelskys is underrated? lol”
H2
“Had a bad, stale bagel at Shelsky’s other day. Elite salmon though.”
H2
“Shelsky’s deli, which is a bit overpriced but good.”
H2
“I’d go there anyway because everything is so good, their bagels are a delight.”
H2
“I second shelsky’s. Big fan of their pastrami egg and cheese on everything.”
H2
“I'd say that's also a great choice, especially if you're looking to get the works (fish, etc) on your bagel.”
H2
“Shelskys and Court street grocers for bagels on your side of Brooklyn - no doubt”
H2
“I also love the Great Gatsby at Shelsky's.”
H2
“they're charging too much for a stale bagel to slip by. It really is about the fish there though.”
H2
“The pork roll egg and cheese is excellent too”
H2
“I was disappointed by Shelskys. Great lox but day old grocery store quality bagel.”
H2
“Shelskys is expensive but excellent”
H2
“My move was dozen bagels from bagel home; 8oz of salmon from Shelsky’s”
H2
“I like shelsky’s for sandwich’s”
H2
“Shelsky’s - king of all mayo-based seafood salads 🐟”
H2
“Shelsky's garlic poppy bialy is good too.”
H2
“Love Shelsky’s horseradish cream cheese!”
H2
“Their hot pastrami special on a bagel is incredible”
H2
“Love the bialies at Shelsky’s in Brooklyn”
H2
“Shelsky's (2 locations) is famous for their lox, cream cheese, bagels. Get their Member of the Tribe bagel.”
H2
“for sourdough bagels- Shelsky’s”
H2
“Shelsky’s for a great bagel”
H2
“I never get sick of the al pastor tacos at taqueria Ramirez or the Clementine gravlax bagel at Shelsky’s.”
H2
“Shelsky's bagels are always salty, and not in a good way.”
H2
“Shelsky’s for a bagel with a schmear”
H2
“So underrated IMO.”
H2
“The Szechuan bagel with Szechuan cream cheese….. sooo good.”
H2
“Like their spreads and the Szechuan innovation but Bagel Hole has much better bagels.”
H2
“This is crazy to me because their bagels IMO are almost as bad as Shelsky’s in terms of how tough they are.”
H2
“Purely in terms of baked good: Kossars, best bagel and shelskys probably.”
H2
“Brownstone bagels is better than shelsjy’s also”
H2
“a Brooklyn Native sandwich from Shelsky's (nova lox, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring, and pickles) was a close second for breakfast.”
H2
“Extremely underrated IMO. Used to live right there and miss it everyday.”
H2
“You could go to shelsky’s or textbook cafe for better bagel or pastry/coffee.”
H2
H1
“Shelsky’s”
H1
“Shelskys”
H1
“Other direction, Shelsky’s.”
H1
“they make a great one.”
H1
“Shelskys? Not even the best one in the neighborhood”
H1
“Park Slope - Bagel Hole Bagel Pub Shelsky's”
H1
“Shelsky’s has both and they’re pretty good.”
H1
“Or, as other have said, Shelskys, Ess a Bagel.”
H1
“We get Shelsky's at work (I'm a caterer) and they're trash.”
H1