“shelskys for a “member of the tribe” on a bialy”
H2
5.8/10
AI-generated summary
Go for the . The Member of the Tribe on a is the order people name most, and the is worth the splurge. The itself is the argument, with several people reporting stale, tough or oversalted ones and pointing to Hole instead. It's expensive either way.
“shelskys for a “member of the tribe” on a bialy”
H2
“Shelsky's on Atlantic Ave. is top tier. Not cheap, but very high quality.”
H2
“Shelsky's in Brooklyn has a great pretzel bagel”
H2
“Shelsky’s salmon on a bialy is always worth the splurge.”
H2
“Shelskys does a good whitefish salad”
H2
“Shelskys for a bialy and lox (specifically Member of the Tribe)”
H2
“am I crazy to think shelskys is underrated? lol”
H2
“Had a bad, stale bagel at Shelsky’s other day. Elite salmon though.”
H2
“Shelsky’s deli, which is a bit overpriced but good.”
H2
“I’d go there anyway because everything is so good, their bagels are a delight.”
H2
“I second shelsky’s. Big fan of their pastrami egg and cheese on everything.”
H2
“I'd say that's also a great choice, especially if you're looking to get the works (fish, etc) on your bagel.”
H2