“Club A Steakhouse and 4 Charles chars their ribeye, if you like the way Peter Luger chars their ribeye and porterhouse but want it high end lightly charred ribeye with better flavor, Club A and 4 Charles is your place.”
H3
All 79 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Club A Steakhouse and 4 Charles chars their ribeye, if you like the way Peter Luger chars their ribeye and porterhouse but want it high end lightly charred ribeye with better flavor, Club A and 4 Charles is your place.”
H3
“The food itself was exactly what I would expect from a solid New York steakhouse. The filet arrived cooked to a perfect medium rare with a well-developed crust while remaining very tender inside.”
H3
“The strip steak was one of the most delicious I've ever had - and I've been to both locations of Striphouse, Casa Lever, Empire, Gallagher's and Keens (I'll have to admit I haven't had a proper steak at Gallagher's due to it being just past 4pm and not being prepared to pay the full price, so I got some other variation, wasn't a steak), and I still think Club A has the best temperature and most flavorful.”
H3
“Club A steakhouse- 6/10, elevated version of Peter Luger. They lightly char the steak but do it much better.”
H2
“Another fave steakhouse is Club A on E 58th. I think it’s a total gem in an old brownstone… :-)”
H2
“one of the most mediocre/expensive dining experiences I’ve ever had”
H2
“There was a 20 oz bone in ribeye that I had at Club A Steakhouse seven months ago that fit the description.”
H2
“It's an excellent value for a steak”
H2
“Didn't like it last year. Poor quality steak and a terrible tiramisu.”
H2
“Club A has a great, reserved ambiance and squeezes in just under your threshold at 58th st.”
H2
“Club A is nice. The food is not outstanding but sometimes they have live jazz, the walls are red. Its a cool vibe.”
H2
“I really like Club A. It’s so charming & service is great!”
H2
“It has more than just steak (decent fish too), and at night w lights outside can be rather nice!”
H2
“Club A is better than all of those.”
H2
“Service is 🤌”
H2
“Not in any order, but all are worth a try…”
H2
“Club A is fine ... decent value, but really not memorable.”
H2
“its my go-to, no fuss steak house that has good service and pretty good food”
H2
“Excellent, intimate and probably the most tender porterhouse I've had...and Ive been to all the NY steakhouses.”
H2
“Club A in midtown is an overlooked steakhouse with great food and service”
H2
“Club A in midtown is an overlooked steakhouse with great food and service”
H2
“Most delicious steak and enormous. nY strip.”
H2
“I’m a big fan of both. Club A for the hospitality and they have a killer chicken parm pizza”
H2
“Definitely a great steak!”
H2
“Keen's, Benjamin, Gallagher's, Striphouse, Quality Meats, and Club A in that order.”
H1
H1
“Keen's, Smith & Wollensky, Club A, Sparks, or Old Homestead.”
H1
“Club A and Strip House on W 12th are my personal favorites.”
H1
“Club A is convenient if you're near Bloomingdales or elsewhere in Midtown East, but it's about average re: quality.”
H1
“Club A”
H1
“Club A”
H1
“Club A”
H1
“Club A”
H1
“Club A ftw”
H1
“Go to Club A Steakhouse. You won’t be disappointed!!!”
H1
“Club A and Vinyl are two great options.”
H1
“Another vote for Keens or Club A”
H1
“Been here multiple times and have always had an excellent meal and experience. Have hit most of the major ones, but there is something about Club A that is sooo good.”
H1
“For the money it’s Club A”
H1
“Club A”
H1
“My go to steakhouses are [The Loft Steakhouse](https://maps.app.goo.gl/4WsezbhZAWEX3UTz9?g_st=ic), [Club A](https://maps.app.goo.gl/ajYHE7QT8vHJeFR66?g_st=ic), and Keens.”
H1
“Clubs A”
H1
“If you want to experience more of an old school NYC, all these places are fantastic minus maybe Quality Meats (which is a bit more modern).”
H1
“I think all 5 are well worth the price of admission in terms of food, ambience, drinks, etc. when compared to similar steakhouses”
H1
“Club A is my favorite in the city.”
H1
“Club A.”
H1
“My favorite steakhouse in the city.”
H1
“Club A”
H1
“Club A”
H1
“I had a great experience at club A. Fun interior and nice owner.”
H1