“Club A Steakhouse and 4 Charles chars their ribeye, if you like the way Peter Luger chars their ribeye and porterhouse but want it high end lightly charred ribeye with better flavor, Club A and 4 Charles is your place.”
H3
6.5/10American
AI-generated summary
People disagree about Club A. Fans say the lightly charred is a bargain next to the big name steakhouses, and the is the side to get. Others call it average and forgettable for the money, and a few say the is bad. The old brownstone room with red walls and live jazz wins people over.
“Club A Steakhouse and 4 Charles chars their ribeye, if you like the way Peter Luger chars their ribeye and porterhouse but want it high end lightly charred ribeye with better flavor, Club A and 4 Charles is your place.”
H3
“The food itself was exactly what I would expect from a solid New York steakhouse. The filet arrived cooked to a perfect medium rare with a well-developed crust while remaining very tender inside.”
H3
“The strip steak was one of the most delicious I've ever had - and I've been to both locations of Striphouse, Casa Lever, Empire, Gallagher's and Keens (I'll have to admit I haven't had a proper steak at Gallagher's due to it being just past 4pm and not being prepared to pay the full price, so I got some other variation, wasn't a steak), and I still think Club A has the best temperature and most flavorful.”
H3
“Club A steakhouse- 6/10, elevated version of Peter Luger. They lightly char the steak but do it much better.”
H2
“Another fave steakhouse is Club A on E 58th. I think it’s a total gem in an old brownstone… :-)”
H2
“one of the most mediocre/expensive dining experiences I’ve ever had”
H2
“There was a 20 oz bone in ribeye that I had at Club A Steakhouse seven months ago that fit the description.”
H2
“It's an excellent value for a steak”
H2
“Didn't like it last year. Poor quality steak and a terrible tiramisu.”
H2
“Club A has a great, reserved ambiance and squeezes in just under your threshold at 58th st.”
H2
“Club A is nice. The food is not outstanding but sometimes they have live jazz, the walls are red. Its a cool vibe.”
H2
“I really like Club A. It’s so charming & service is great!”
H2