All 87 rated mentions, most helpful first
“The mocktail, octopus salad, and hazelnut semifreddo were all delicious but I actually found the pasta underwhelming. This was the scallop tonnarelli and the whole dish tasted fishy, plus the cherry tomatoes were barely warmed, which I found odd. Disappointed overall.”
H3
“Nonna Dora’s is one of my all-time favorite restaurants in the city.”
H3
“The best pasta I’ve ever had in NYC! You will not be disappointed!”
H3
“I had the orechiette and was unimpressed.”
H2
“Nonna Dora. If you go at lunch she is likely to be there making the pasta”
H2
“Love the lasagna at Nonna Dora’s on 2nd between 33rd/34th. The other food is great as well, and the beverage program is fantastic.”
H2
“But it felt like they were intentionally ignoring me. I almost missed my Broadway show at 7 even though I had a 5pm reservation”
H2
“Nonna Dora for pasta and a great Negroni menu.”
H2
“Nonna Dora has great pasta!”
H2
“The first time I had the Melanzana at Nonna Dora, my eyes rolled back in my head with how good it was.”
H2
“Melanzana at Nonna Dora”
H2
“If it’s fresh pasta you’re after, try Nonna Dora’s or Rezdôra.”
H2
“Nonna Dora's is pretty good for gluten free pasta.”
H2
“All handmade pasta with an amazing pasta tasting menu.”
H2
“excellent pasta and wine/cocktail program”
H2
“I love the eggplant parm at Nonna Dora’s.”
H2
“love it there! small and cozy and unpretentious. just good pasta.”
H2
“Nonna Dora is awful pasta in a cramped space... the bar in the back is literally across from the pasta stations and deep fryers.”
H2
“Pasta- nonna Dora, norma, il buco”
H2
“Nonna Dora’s in Murray Hill for fresh pasta and tiramisu. They have a good three course meal deal with lots of different options”
H2
“Nonna Dora’s has a whole Negroni menu with some pretty solid options”
H2
“Nonna Dora's boar ragu”
H2
“I third this rec, they have every pasta shape available as gluten free and are in Kips Bay so walking distance from Penn, Madison Square Park, etc. Plus tasty and not a difficult res / doable walk in!”
H2
H1
“I love eating at the bar at Nonna Dora”
H1
“That said, look up Nonna Dora's on 2nd Ave.”
H1
“Skip - Porto Rico, Grace St, Balthazar, Yasouvlaki, Nonna Dora, Bubbys, La Bonne Soup, Da Toscano”
H1
“Nonna Dora is a gem”
H1
“Hmm. To name a few top of my head: Malatesta, Malaparte, Frankie's 457, Norma, Donna Margherita, Nonna Dora, Piccola Cucina.”
H1
“Nonna Dora”
H1
“I feel like Nonna Dora’s is a good option that you don’t have to book, like, a month in advance, and they have a big menu.”
H1
“Nonna dora was great!”
H1
“It’s really, really freaking good.”
H1
“Nonna Dora is great”
H1
“Nonna Dora’s - they have a downtown and midtown location. Cool story too!”
H1
“Nonna Dora is awesome. Went again two weeks ago”
H1
“Look up Nonna Dora on 2nd Ave (not French, but fun)”
H1
“Nonna Dora’s!”
H1
“Nonna Dora is right by that ferry stop and is one of my favorite pasta places in the city! It’s in a weird location but it’s SO good and has great ambiance”
H1
“Cervo’s, Nonna Dora’s, Wu’s Wonton King, KJUN, All’Antico Vinaio. Basing this more on places I love to go regularly.”
H1
“Hojokban, Stretch Pizza, 5ive Spice, Nonna Dora’s”
H1
“I always opt for the bar and service is nice. Last time I went, we got treated so well at the bar”
H1
“Nonna Dora”
H1
“fiaschetteria pistoia and nonna dora’s are fantastic”
H1
“Nonna Dora, NY Bagel by the hospital, Lan Larb, Norma, Pio Pio, Eon’s”
H1
“Nonna dora was great!”
H1
“I was underwhelmed by Nonna Dora’s.”
H1
“nonna dora’s is kinda upscale and a realistic res for 8”
H1
“nonna Dora is an absolute under the radar gem”
H1
“Nonna Dora in Murry Hill for pasta and Sotto Casa in Harlem for pizza (way better than Song). Both unlikely, both delicious”
H1