“Very solid cheesesteaks with proper options/cheeses/toppings. They bring in the bread and soft pretzels from Philly. Only done takeout and never been disappointed.”
H3
All 92 rated mentions, most helpful first
“Very solid cheesesteaks with proper options/cheeses/toppings. They bring in the bread and soft pretzels from Philly. Only done takeout and never been disappointed.”
H3
“I’ve only ever gotten Olde City through delivery (several times) and I agree they’re bland and usually don’t have as much filling as in the photo posted here. Their bread is also inconsistent (sometimes toasted well, sometimes not).”
H3
“They changed their bread and I think it ruins the cheesesteak now. It used to be a nice crispy crust, soft interior. Now it's like a sponge/soft/no crisp or taste. Low quality grocery store sort of roll.”
H3
“the meat were very dry & tough, and there was barely any cheese (many bites with no cheese).”
H3
“But I do dig the Cheese steaks at Olde City. And the fact that you can sub in chicken is also dope at Olde (juiciest chicken over there).”
H2
“Olde City has a $20 cheesesteak / fries / beer lunch special that's actually pretty amazing.”
H2
“Shortys / olde city is your classic bar cheesesteak, nothing fancy. Kind of stuff you grew up on and very nostalgic”
H2
“Olde city cheesteaks are better though, and have a fantastic lunch special for $20 roughly with a side and drink”
H2
“Yes, they're super legit. I eat there for lunch at least once a week, please don't tell my wife. The authentic with wiz & onions is my jam.”
H2
“The italian fries are fucking fantastic.”
H2
“Olde City is the best I’ve found, near Flatiron and they deliver.”
H2
“Def better than Wogies/Olde City IMO.”
H2
“I attribute it more to a local spot cheesesteak than a “best cheesesteak”, but it definitely gets the job done and is authentic”
H2
“I like Olde City. It's not comparable to, like, Jim's, but it's a perfectly good steak.”
H2
“olde city city is better (get their cheese steak eggrolls too)”
H2
“Olde City's are amazing”
H2
“Olde City’s is better.”
H2
“Olde city cheesesteaks and roasted pork sandwiches”
H2
“olde city cheesesteaks in Hell's Kitchen. More of a bar atmosphere than sit down restaurant but they do have tables and a sandwich forward menu”
H2
“Olde City (special cheesesteak specials)”
H2
“Old city started out as Shorty’s and was a collaboration with Tony Luke’s in Philly. Very authentic”
H2
“Also Olde City cheesesteaks around the corner is a really good cheesesteak”
H2
“Their roast pork is good too”
H2
“Cheesesteaks are good but god I’ll never go back to that location”
H2
“But if you want a good fresh pretzel, go to olde city cheesesteaks”
H2
“there’s a place called Olde City Cheesesteaks that does a really tasty soft pretzel”
H2
“Olde city has good wings”
H2
“I spent time in Philly, and honestly even the likes of ishkabibbles, dalessandros, etc does not compare to olde city’s steaks.”
H2
“Olde City’s with cooper sharp is solid”
H2
“Olde City is good as well specifically because they use cooper sharp.”
H2
“not anymore, they switched their bread and it sucks now because of it.”
H2
“Olde city actually makes a really good cheesesteak especially for bar food.”
H2
“Better than olde city which can be hit or miss sometimes.”
H2
“Olde city!”
H1
“If you’re craving a pork roll or Philly cheese steak I recommend either (1) wogies or (2) olde city cheesesteaks.”
H1
“Olde city is pretty good!”
H1
“Old city or fedderoffs.”
H1
“Food is really good and fun for game days!”
H1
“Olde City rules.”
H1
“Olde City is the new name for Shorty’s. It’s solid”
H1
“It's a chain but Olde City is delicious, I've been to the one on 9th Ave multiple times and they are delicious.”
H1
“Olde city”
H1
“Olde City is awesome, great bar food”
H1
H1
“I think so, but I still appreciate that you can get wiz at Olde City!”
H1
“Wogie's in Fidi or Olde City on the UES are both decent”
H1
“2. Federoff's 3. Olde City (used to be shorty's)”
H1
“Olde City on Madison Ave”
H1
“Need to go back to Olde City sooner than later to get a proper one”
H1
“Olde City”
H1