Il Mulino

All 87 rated mentions, most helpful first

in:What's the best and most expensive restaurant you've ever been to here?7 pts
“Randomly I also like Il Mulino (the original one) for a long, decadent group dinner and you can easily hit $1000 with a group of 4 or 6. Never had a bad time there.”
H2
in:Italian restaurant recommendations?7 pts
“Il Mulino is very overrated and always has been in my mind.”
H2
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?7 pts
“The OG Il Mulino has an insane parm”
H2
in:Did I do OK with these reservations?7 pts
“Il Mulino on West 3rd is amazing. Their veal chop is the best in the city”
H2
in:Great red gravy Italian in Manhattan?5 pts
replying to u/DC25NYC: Bamontes and carmines. Also for higher end but could def take kids, One of my faves is Emilio’s Ballato
“I personally find Il Mulino overpriced for what it is, but it’s quite good.”
H2
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?4 pts
replying to u/Spaghetti-Bandit: Il mulino in west village
“Just went to UES location last week and love love loved the chicken parm”
H2
in:Chicken Scarpariello - does nobody know how to make this correctly?2 pts
“Il Mulino has a serviceable one in terms of flavor notes but is bereft of any accoutrements.”
H2
in:Best places for cheesecake in NYC?1 pts
“IL Mulino has the best cheesecake in the world. In one week I had 13 slices of”
H2
in:Best places for cheesecake in NYC?1 pts
“IL Mulino Best I have ever had. Perfection”
H2
in:First Time New York1 pts
“Best cheesecake I have ever had in my travels and add in the fresh berries with table side preparation in a copper pot.”
H2
in:Lamb Chops?1 pts
“Great, but expensive.”
H2
in:Italian Restaurants overlooked by Eater NY1 pts
“Can’t beat the original Il Mulino on 3rd St. No frills, no social media plugs, just exceptional real Italian food, not chicken parm this or that.”
H2
in:What’s been the best Truffle Pasta you’ve had in the city?1 pts
“They were *very* generous with the truffle shavings.”
H2
in:Where to take my mom in NYC for an unforgettable birthday dinner experience?1 pts
“A well kept secret for that kind of treatment (not quite singing) is il Mulino. Service is so attentive and will go above and beyond to make your evening special if you mention it’s a special occasion.”
H2
in:Michelin Star for Tough Mother In Law1 pts
“Just take her to Il Mulino. It’s not Michelin starred but it’s fancy feeling and Italian and she’ll think she’s being catered to.”
H2
in:Best chicken parm in NY?-1 pts
“You an get absolutely delicious chicken Parm at il mulino, trattoria del arte, bond 45.”
H2
in:Can yall weigh in on the list I made for restaurants to eat at during my visit in July?25 pts
“or better run upscale spots like Casa Lever or il Mulino.”
H1
in:Best chicken parm in NY?14 pts
replying to u/MarinaraBoss: Emilio's Ballato
“Honorable mentions to Il Mulino and La Masseria.”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?12 pts
“Il mulino in west village”
H1
in:Where are your must go-to’s for restaurant week this summer?11 pts
“Same goes for Il Mulino.”
H1
in:Best chicken parm in NY?11 pts
“Il Mulino or Cafe Fiorello”
H1
in:Authentic Italian American Restaurant - Manhattan10 pts
“Il Mulino”
H1
in:Dinner Near St. Patrick’s Cathedral Before a 7pm Show??8 pts
“Il Mulino on 56th Street - classic good Italian.”
H1
in:Italian restaurant for a tourist7 pts
“Went to Il Mulino for my birthday recently and super old school and really loved it.”
H1
in:What are restaurants past their hype, but still solid for a first time diner?7 pts
“Il Mulino”
H1
in:NYC's Best Chicken Parm?6 pts
replying to u/Spaghetti-Bandit: Il mulino in west village
“Insane”
H1
in:NYC Traditional Italian Recommendations6 pts
“Otherwise go to the original Il Mulino in the village.”
H1
in:an NYC restaurant that is so good and yet still relatively easy to get into?5 pts
“Il Mulino (the original in West Village)”
H1
in:NYC Birthday Dinner with my Girlfriend5 pts
“Il Mulino is a can't miss pick imo”
H1
in:Best Chicken Parm near midtown? 5 pts
“Il Mulino is a great option”
H1
in:Best Italian in the Village?5 pts
“Bar pitti, il cantinori, 1 fifth, lupa, babbo, il mulino”
H1
in:Best steakhouse5 pts
“Il mulino for Italian.”
H1
in:Last month in NYC: pls help with bucket list4 pts
“Il Mulino not bucket list”
H1
in:Your best Italian recommendation for dinner 4 pts
“If you want to stay up town: Il Mulino”
H1
in:Best food within reasonable walking distance of LES? 4 pts
“Il Mulino is much easier reservation to get and still pretty good.”
H1
in:Best Italian restaurants in Manhattan4 pts
“the Ci Ciamos, Il Mulino, and L’artusis of the world are just simply great chefs/reataurant and their menu is Italian”
H1
in:What are some good Italian restaurants to take 7 midwestern dudes (all in their 60s) who have never been to NYC?4 pts
“If they want real old school Il Mulino downtown.”
H1
in:Italian restaurant for birthday4 pts
“Il Mulino on West 3rd”
H1
in:Looking for a good Italian restaurant budget 200$-300$3 pts
“Il mulino”
H1
in:Solid Italian near Bryant Park?3 pts
“il mulino”
H1
in:Authentic Italian American Restaurant - Manhattan3 pts
replying to u/xlaurenthead: Il Mulino
“not as good in recent years imo”
H1
in:Favorite Italian restaurant in midtown w reasonable prices 3 pts
“il Mulino, as well as other mentioned in this thread”
H1
in:Italian restaurant recommendations?3 pts
“Il Mulino on West 3rd”
H1
in:Best chicken parm in NY?3 pts
“Il Mulino downtown”
H1
in:Looking for the BEST Italian downtown3 pts
“I Sodi, Morandi, Rosemarys, Lupa, Il Mulino to name a few”
H1
in:Memorable Italian Restaurant?3 pts
“Ci Siamo, Il Mulino, Piccolo Cucina are some of the more memorable italian restaurants i've been to as of late”
H1
in:Best chicken parm in Manhattan?3 pts
“Il Mulino”
H1
in:Looking for a great mushroom risotto (wife’s request!)3 pts
“Il mulino on the UES might be your best bet for overall but it’s def pricey”
H1
in:Pasta2 pts
“Also il mulino.”
H1
in:Hype-y / Showy places to take guests2 pts
“Hutong, Per Se, Coté, Blue Ribbon Sushi & Steak, Keen’s, Quality Meats, Il Mulino, Ippudo”
H1