“The cake was amazing—moist, flavorful, and just packed with the right stuff. But the icing? A bit of a letdown for me. Still, Lloyd’s is up there among the best I have had”
H3
All 94 rated mentions, most helpful first
“The cake was amazing—moist, flavorful, and just packed with the right stuff. But the icing? A bit of a letdown for me. Still, Lloyd’s is up there among the best I have had”
H3
“Lloyd's frosting takes them out of the GOAT running for me. It's way too sweet and you can barely taste any cream cheese tang which is essential in a good carrot cake.”
H3
“I absolutely agree. I find the cake very dense and oily. The icing is obviously made with artificial vanilla. The whole thing is way too sweet. I have no idea why people line up for this.”
H3
“this was my biggest disappointment on my NY trip. Found the texture amazing, perfect in fact but no flavour at all, even the cream cheese just tasted sugary.”
H3
“Lloyd’s Carrot Cake always”
H2
“I had llyods carrot cake last time I went, and it was phenomenal.”
H2
“Lloyd's Carrot Cake.”
H2
“When looking for carrot cake in NY, the answer is always Lloyds.”
H2
“Lloyd's Carrot Cake because that's what carrot cake should be.”
H2
“I was not impressed with Lloyd's carrot cake when I had it”
H2
“The 5 best I’ve had: Lloyds”
H2
“its still good, but the level of sweetness all around has gone up at least 25%.. too sweet for my taste”
H2
“Lloyd's Carrot Cake, because it's carrot cake the way it's supposed to be: a spice cake.”
H2
“It's the only carrot cake I've enjoyed, because it's really a spice cake (which is what I think carrot cake should be).”
H2
“my favorite non Hani’s / old school NYC carrot cakes in the city come from Lloyd’s and Amy’s Bread.”
H2
“If you get Lloyd's carrot cake unfrosted, it will hold up. I once took it to Ithaca and it was great even the next day.”
H2
“Hard agree. Very overrated imo”
H2
“i find lloyds carrot cake one is light and taste amazing and cheesy”
H2
“while best fresh and still warm, it will last a day.”
H2
“Lloyd’s Carrot Cake”
H2
“Not lunch but for the love of all things good and holy, stop by Lloyd’s Carrot Cake. I survived on their carrot cake in college at their original location.”
H2
“The Carrot Cake is so good that it outshines the best Red Velvet in the city.”
H2
“lloyd's carrot cake - they deliver to the bronx”
H2
“Go to Lloyd’s in the bx to get some carrot cake”
H2
“This is the only correct answer. I get the plain carrot cake and it’s phenomenal.”
H2
“S&S Cheesecake or Lloyd's Carrot Cake for the Bronx.”
H2
“I think their red velvet is actually better than their carrot cake”
H2
“I dont like carrot cake but this was amazing.”
H2
“Too sweet, icing needs to be more savoury with cream cheese. Good for the price though.”
H2
“Carrot cake: Lloyds”
H2
“Amazing cake *and* they are an iconic New York establishment.”
H2
“Best in the city for carrot cake.”
H2
“lloyd’s carrot cake in east harlem is consistently good.”
H2
“Agree! Lloyd was dry to me”
H2
“Same, didn’t care much for carrot cake until Lloyd’s!”
H2
“The carrot cake at Lloyd's is better for literally a quarter of the price.”
H2
“Lloyds Carrot Cake in the BX”
H2
“Lloyds carrot cake 🤩”
H2
“the rarebit burger at Lloyd's is super cheesy, a little too cheesy for me”
H2
“+1 to this. One of the best carrot cakes.”
H2
“Yes, def get Lloyds carrot cake!”
H2
“I thought Lloyd's had a really good and moist cake but a horrible super sweet frosting.”
H2
“Lloyds red velvet is a sleeper”
H2
“I had it. Frosting is good but cake is bland”
H2
“Lloyds carrot cake”
H2
“Lloyd’s Carrot Cake has a truly excellent double chocolate slice too.”
H2
“I had this cake today and it tasted entirely of oil.”
H2
“Lloyd's Carrot Cake is an excellent spice cake with a good hit of molasses and ginger.”
H2
“Carrot cake: - Lloyd's”
H2
“Lloyds carrot cake with nuts and raisins 🥰”
H2