“The cake was amazing—moist, flavorful, and just packed with the right stuff. But the icing? A bit of a letdown for me. Still, Lloyd’s is up there among the best I have had”
H3
7.6/10
AI-generated summary
Get the . It's really a spice , heavy on molasses and ginger, and people call it the best in the city for the price. People split on the icing. Plenty find it way too sweet with no cream cheese tang, and a few say the itself tastes oily. The is a sleeper pick.
“The cake was amazing—moist, flavorful, and just packed with the right stuff. But the icing? A bit of a letdown for me. Still, Lloyd’s is up there among the best I have had”
H3
“Lloyd's frosting takes them out of the GOAT running for me. It's way too sweet and you can barely taste any cream cheese tang which is essential in a good carrot cake.”
H3
“I absolutely agree. I find the cake very dense and oily. The icing is obviously made with artificial vanilla. The whole thing is way too sweet. I have no idea why people line up for this.”
H3
“this was my biggest disappointment on my NY trip. Found the texture amazing, perfect in fact but no flavour at all, even the cream cheese just tasted sugary.”
H3
“Lloyd’s Carrot Cake always”
H2
“I had llyods carrot cake last time I went, and it was phenomenal.”
H2
“Lloyd's Carrot Cake.”
H2
“When looking for carrot cake in NY, the answer is always Lloyds.”
H2
“Lloyd's Carrot Cake because that's what carrot cake should be.”
H2
“I was not impressed with Lloyd's carrot cake when I had it”
H2
“The 5 best I’ve had: Lloyds”
H2
“its still good, but the level of sweetness all around has gone up at least 25%.. too sweet for my taste”
H2